Thread: LA County Supes renew controversial 287g partnership between Sheriff's Dept. and ICE

LA County Supes renew controversial partnership between Sheriff's Dept. and ICE

Leslie Berestein Rojas
an hour ago

Supporters of the federal-local enforcement partnership known as in 287(g) in L.A. County jails say the program can identify deportable inmates that that Secure Communities might miss - and that this helps with the cost of incarcerating them, as the county gets partially reimbursed for jailing foreign-born criminals. JOHN MOORE/GETTY IMAGES


SLIDESHOW

The Los Angeles County supervisors voted Tuesday to stick with a controversial federal-local immigration enforcement program known as 287(g), making Los Angeles one of just two counties in the state to still use it — and one of a relative handful in the country.

Supervisors Gloria Molina, Michael Antonovich and Don Knabe voted in favor of renewing the program. Mark Ridley-Thomas and Zev Yaroslavsky abstained.

Dozens of people commented before the vote, virtually all of them speaking against the 287(g) program. At one point, protesters turned their backs on the supervisors, to show their disapproval of the county's partnership with federal immigration officials.

Named for a section of the immigration law that authorizes it,287(g) essentially deputizes county cops to perform immigration enforcement tasks. It's been used by the Sheriff’s Department in local jails since 2005, with deputies trained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents to screen convicted inmates in the jail system for their immigration status.

While it was never widely used, 287(g) has become fairly rare: At its height, 75 jurisdictions in the country used it. The fedsscaled the program back in late 2012 in favor of the newer, more cost-effective Secure Communities. Today, only 35 jurisdictions in the country still use it.

So why would L.A. County keep 287(g), even as law enforcement agencies around the U.S. are limiting their cooperation with immigration agents?

Supporters say it's for one of the same reasons the feds have not dismantled it completely: The in-depth screening interviews done in jails by local cops under 287(g) can identify people that the Secure Communities can miss.

From a law enforcement perspective, this gets more criminals into deportation proceedings. But identifying these inmates is also in the county's financial interest.

"It helps us maintain better records for the purpose of reimbursement from the federal government," said Anna Pembedjian, justice deputy for County Supervisor Michael Antonovich, a supporter of 287(g).

What Pembedjian is referring to is a federal grant program known as SCAAP, for State Criminal Alien Assistance Program. Counties like Los Angeles are partially reimbursed by the Department of Justice for incarcerating certain foreign-born criminals, and the better they can document their inmate population, the better their reimbursement chances.

SCAAP funds may be used for relatively broad costs, like correctional officers' salaries, training and education for offenders, new prison facilities and other related costs. Applications for funds are filled out annually.

But in recent years, funding has been cut. Los Angeles County’s annual SCAAP award has gone from roughly $15 million in the late 2000s to about $3.4 million in 2014.

The county now gets reimbursed roughly 10 cents on the dollar for every SCAAP-eligible foreign inmate, Pembedjian said. Less than before, but it’s money the county would otherwise still have to spend.

“When these individuals are arrested and serving time in our jails, we have no alternative but to provide them with the housing, the mental health care, the medical care, food and security, which costs the county taxpayers millions of dollars every year,” Pembedjian said. “It is imperative for the county to recover the money from the federal government, otherwise if forces cuts in other vital services.”

POPULAR NOW ON MULTI-AMERICAN


287(g): LA County sticks with controversial program

287(g) predates Secure Communities, launched in 2008. It performs a similar function, but on the receiving end: Fingerprints of people taken into custody by local cops are checked against a federal database, and if there’s is a match with Homeland Security records, immigration agents are alerted.

Unlike with 287(g), participation in Secure Communities isn't optional. The program was expanded in early 2013 to agencies around the country. But because it's automated and works via a database, it's not foolproof – for example, it might miss someone who is in the country illegally but has never encountered authorities.

"That's why in-person screenings, like the ones conducted by local law enforcement personnel under the 287(g) program, are of value," said Virginia Kice, a spokeswoman for ICE in Los Angeles. "In these face to face encounters, we'll potentially identify individuals who are an enforcement priority for ICE...who might have gone undetected because their fingerprints weren't in DHS' database."

The agency has long had ICE agents in county jails in a supervisory capacity to review 287(g) cases, Kice said, and they also screen inmates.

The L.A. County Sheriff’s Department had recommended to supervisors that the 287(g) contract be extended. It’s rankled immigrant advocates, who planned to protest at Tuesday’s meeting. They said a yes vote would have the county moving against the current, as more local agencies limit how much they cooperate with immigration agents.

In California, a new law known as the Trust Act now limits who local agencies can hold at immigration agents’ request once they’re otherwise eligible to be released.

“The TRUST Act passed one year ago was a major step forward followed by Los Angeles refusing to submit to immigration’s unconstitutional detainer requests,” said immigrant rights advocate Pablo Alvarado, of the National Day Laborer Organizing Network, in an emailed statement before the Tuesday vote. “Now the Board has the opportunity to further remove Arizona-style policies from LA’s books.”

Other local counties have dropped 287(g), leaving just Los Angeles and Orange participating. San Bernardino and Riverside both dropped it recently. San Bernardino County Sheriff’s detective Lolita Harper said passage of the Trust Act is one reason county officials began to reconsider.

Then earlier this year, an Oregon court ruled that issuing ICE detainers without probably cause could be a violation of constitutional rights, opening local agencies who issue them to liability.

“Once we got word of that decision, that is when we decided to suspend the program completely,” Harper said. “For us, it was pertinent because we were still using our 287(g) program.”

Los Angeles was among the local counties that said they they would stop honoring immigration detainer requests after the Oregon ruling, although advocates say the policy hasn't been applied evenly.

Pembedjian and other 287(g) supporters in L.A. County say that in any case, legal exposure isn't so much of a concern locally because unlike in some other agencies, the Sheriff’s Department uses 287(g) to screen inmates post-conviction, once they've already been convicted of a crime.

After they’ve served their time, they’re turned over to ICE.

http://www.scpr.org/blogs/multiameri...87-g-a-little/

5/16/2011

http://www.alipac.us/f12/l-sheriff-l...d-guys-227176/

9/12/2013

http://www.alipac.us/f12/la-county-s...grants-287480/

http://www.alipac.us/f12/375-031-dep...2014-a-311693/

L.A. County supervisors vote to extend ICE deal in jails

A Los Angeles County sheriff's deputy inside the Twin Towers Correctional Facility. (Patrick T. Fallon / Bloomberg)

By KATE LINTHICUM contact the reporter

L.A. County will extend a controversial partnership with federal immigration authorities in county jails

L.A. County supervisors vote to extend ICE presence in jails


The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to extend a controversial partnership with federal immigration authorities designed to target potentially deportable immigrants who have been convicted of serious crimes.

The board voted 3-0 to extend the contract after a tense hearing in which dozens of activists blamed the program for eroding trust in law enforcement among immigrant communities.


Supervisors to weigh county jails' collaboration with ICE agents Kate Linthicum


The program, known as 287(g), places federal immigration agents inside county jails and trains jail employees to investigate whether inmates convicted of certain crimes are in the country illegally.

Inmates identified through the program are often turned over to federal authorities after they are released from jail.

Supervisors Gloria Molina, Don Knabe and Michael Antonovich voted to approve the agreement. Supervisors Zev Yaroslavsky and Mark Ridley-Thomas abstained.

Yaroslavsky said he wanted to see more data on the program, saying quarterly reports produced by the Sheriff's Department since 2010 have been "superficial."

lRelated
EDUCATION Mexico's president thanks California leaders for welcoming immigrants SEE ALL RELATED

He held up a one-page report sent to the board in August that he said included little more than the number of interviews conducted by ICE-trained jail employees (339 during a three-month period that ended July 31), and called for more detail about what crimes individuals identified through the program had been convicted of.

During Tuesday's hearing, advocates said a host of immigrants without serious criminal records have found themselves in deportation proceedings because of 287(g).


Garcetti aide is face of city's outreach to foreign-born residents Kate Linthicum


Blanca Perez, 34, told the board that she ended up in ICE custody after being arrested for illegally selling ice cream bars outside her son's school in Van Nuys. Perez, a Mexican immigrant who came to the country illegally, said she was transferred from ajail facility to an ICE detention center after an L.A. County sheriff's deputy questioned her about her immigration status.

"Please end this program," she told the supervisors. "It separates families."

Molina, who has been one of the staunchest supporters of 287(g), said her office would investigate the circumstances of Perez's case.

She said serious criminals, not people like Perez, are the program's intended targets.

"We are not here picking up people who are selling lollipops," she said. "We are trying to find a way to make L.A. County safe."

Immigration officials said they could not provide immediate data on how many ICE detainees were identified through the county jail system or what types of crimes those individuals had been convicted of.

A 2010 Migration Policy Institute study of the county's implementation of the program found that of 2,874 federal requests to hold potentially deportable inmates that year, only about a fifth were issued against so-called Level One offenders, which include those convicted of murder, rape and kidnapping.

The rest were issued against people who had committed less serious offenses, including traffic violations, the study found.

Across the country, state and local governments have been reconsidering their relationship with federal immigration officials. The number of law enforcement jurisdictions participating in 287(g) has decreased from 75 to 35 in recent years, according to ICE officials. The only other jurisdiction in California to participate in the program is Orange County.

Several advocates had asked that lawmakers delay the vote until a new sheriff is elected and sworn in. Both candidates vying in the November election to replace interim Sheriff John Scott have voiced opposition to the program.

After the board voted to approve the contract, the board chambers erupted in jeers as immigrant advocates shouted "Molina deports!" in unison. Earlier in the meeting, about 60 advocates stood up and turned their backs to lawmakers for more than an hour in a silent protest.

Twitter: @katelinthcum

http://www.latimes.com/local/la-me-i...008-story.html

Realtime Coverage

Immigration agents will remain in LA County jails SFGate - ‎1 hour ago‎ LOS ANGELES (AP) — Los Angeles County will continue a program that places federal immigration agents inside jails and trains jail employees to investigate whether inmates convicted of certain crimes are in the country illegally. The county's Board of ...