Below are four articles I compiled to use when writing my Senators to request that they vote "No" to Sonia Sotomayor's appointment to the Supreme Court. The 5th is an article already posted here. They are:

1. Sotomayor Ruling Could Have Cost Consumers Billions
2. Sotomayor Faces Scrutiny on Controversial Firefighter Ruling
3. In Sotomayor's Own Words
4. Case Against Sotomayor: Bully on the Bench?
5. Sotomayor Majority Opinions Reversed 60% by Supreme Court


1. Sotomayor Ruling Could Have Cost Consumers Billions
Tuesday, May 26, 2009 10:56 PM
By: Phil Brennan

A decision rendered by Obama Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor, fortunately reversed by the Supreme Court on April 1, 2009, could have been extravagantly costly to American consumers, according to the Steve Milloy's authoritative Junkscience.Com.

Charging that her nomination represents a potential threat to U.S. Consumers and to the economy in terms of energy and the environment, Milloy reported on her 2007 Second Circuit decision in Riverkeeper, Inc. V. EPA 475 F. 3d 83'

Milloy wrote that in her ruling Judge Sotomayor sided with "extreme green groups" who had sued the Environmental Protection Agency because the agency permitted cost-benefit analysis to be used in the determination of environmental protection technology for power plant cooling water intake structures.

Cost benefit analysis involves the balancing of the total expected costs of a proposal or project against its total expected benefits in order to determine its economic feasibility. Do the benefits outweigh or justify the cost?

According to Milloy, had the EPA been required to abide by Judge Sotomayor’s decision, U.S. Consumers would have been forced to pay billions of dollars more in energy costs every year as power plants producing more than one-half of the nation’s electricity would have had to undertake expensive retrofits."

Noting that President Obama said he wanted somebody "who has the intellectual firepower but also a little bit of a common touch and a practical sense of how the world works,â€