Thread: A false choice on immigration

A false choice on immigration

Jan 19, 2011

Sometimes the immigration debate gets so ridiculous that it's no wonder those on opposite sides can't ever agree on how to move forward.

Take, for instance, complaints about the contentious federal Secure Communities program. Run by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), the program identifies illegal immigrants based on fingerprints checked against Department of Justice, FBI and Department of Homeland Security records.

Since the program began in 2007, it has spread to 969 jurisdictions in 37 states and ICE expects all states will be participating by 2013, bolstering the amount of national data-sharing and the agency's ability to fulfill its mission of "prioritizing (enforcement) resources toward the greatest threats, and sharing information between law enforcement partners."

Secure Communities is back on the radar because the Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights, a nationally influential advocacy group, recently released a report detailing the shortcomings of what it considers an intolerable law enforcement strategy that injects fear into the immigrant community, wastes taxpayer money with program implementation costs, and "catches the wrong people."

The report, "The Dangerous Reality Behind 'Secure Communities,'" reiterated concerns that other immigrant advocacy groups have about the program -- and highlighted the vast gap in perceptions about illegal immigration that keep usually level-headed folks from coming to consensus on how to deal with an issue that has rocked both rural and urban communities across the country.

The report touched on important points about the burdens that unfunded federal law enforcement mandates put on already financially rocky municipalities, and the potential for increased distrust between residents and local police. It also makes fair points about a need for more transparency and accountability on ICE's part in reporting detailed data about how Secure Communities operates or current statistics about how it is performing.

But the main beef is the program's track record in identifying illegal immigrants who have no previous criminal convictions and yet are put at high risk for deportation. According to the coalition's calculations, from November 2009 -- when the Illinois State Police signed on to the program and enabled county jails to participate -- through September 2010, 78 percent of the people detained by ICE in Illinois, and 27 percent detained nationally, had never been convicted of a crime.

A Chicago-region ICE spokeswoman responded to reporters' inquiries about the accuracy of the data by offering different figures for Illinois (44 percent) and the U.S. (37 percent) of those lacking a criminal record.

Either way, why is that wrong?

Why is it wrong that people who are living in this country illegally -- because they entered to escape economic deprivation or they overstayed a tourist, student or work visa -- would be subject to deportation if they come in close-enough contact with a law enforcement officer to be fingerprinted?

We're not talking about stupid people here. Immigrants who have left their homes and traveled thousands of miles to create new lives for themselves know they are at a constant risk of being caught and sent home if they don't have proper documents. Few pilgrims tread into our promised land without understanding the risks.

Yet let me be clear: Deportations are a tragedy for separated families and individuals forced to return to poverty and strife. And under no circumstances should illegal immigrants from any country be exploited or treated inhumanely or as unwanted parasites by unscrupulous employers, government bureaucracies or pandering political parties. This country is better than that.

Thank goodness for the well-meaning people providing succor and defense to those caught up in the whirlwind of confusing and sometimes unfair immigrations laws. But advocacy groups such as the Illinois coalition go beyond the limits of compassion when they call on the municipalities involved to stop following certain laws because the lawbreakers in question aren't deemed the "greatest threats" to national security.

The very request elicits such bad will among those who fear mass amnesty that it prevents any realistic conversations on what to do about the estimated 11 million illegal immigrants in the country.

Even worse, it sets up a false choice between an immigration law reform that is either compassionate or just. In reality, with sensible compromises on both ends, there's no reason why it couldn't be a little of both.

Contact Cepeda at estherjcepeda@washpost.com .

http://www.indystar.com/article/2011011 ... ar.com%7Cs

Looks like the Indianapolis crime syndicate is pumping their propaganda.

Adios illegal aliens, please feel free to take the (?)journalists(?) and newspaper with you,.....a parting gift. .......the paper beats corn cobs, and you can use the (?)journalists(?) as mules to haul your belongings back south of the border.

"Nice contact links!"
http://icirr.org/en/node/5225

Perhaps the words "Illegal alien" just evades the pea brain well-meaning people

The whirlwind of "confusing" and sometimes "unfair" immigrations laws?
Moron,............Enough said.

By my independant studies 100% of illegal aliens have commited a crime. Ohh and thats by legal standards not nutcase thinking. They are detained and either given some form of waiver (boo!), or deported. If they didn't commit a crime they would have been released with an apology. Of course they did commit a crime... which is being in our Country illegally. And last I checked its still considered a crime by US law.

There is no middle ground, there is no room for compromise, there is no reason at all for "separating families" when the entire family should be deported, dual citizen children included so they transfer with the family, and there is no cause for this debate at all.

Our existing immigration laws are the fairest and most just immigration laws of any country in the world. The solution is not complicated, it's very simple: we secure our borers, unleash 800,000 state and local law enforcement officrs to enforce US immigration law, curtail all benefits to illegal aliens including automatic birthright citizenship and streamline the deportations so we can get these people out of here on the earliest possible date.

We don't need or want immigration "reform" (that would benefit illegal aliens), the system works fine. We need and demand enforcement!

We want Secure Communities and we want illegal aliens deported.

What the media fails to recondize is families were broken by the illegals coming to the usa in the first place no where have I ever seen or heard of a whole family sneeking across the boarder at one time! So in my mind if they get shipped back in peices its kinda the same way they got here right? So then the only concern would be the ancor babies and to that I say if you don't want to take your children with you while your being deported your only option would be to leave them with a compadent realitive. Quit expecting american citizens to pick up the slack for people who think they can break the law by coming here and not following the laws! We as citizens of this country have been punished enough with the over crowding of our school the loss of our hospitals etc etc we as american citizens understandd that where these people are coming from is sufering from poverty but the solution is not for our goverment our states our citys our people to carry the burden! Its mexico goverment, states, cities, peoples problem they need to work on a solution. It is our best intrest for the mexican gov to step up and really become self sufficent and really take care of their people

Good point moptop. We often hear about illegals sending money back home to their wife and 15 children.

Originally Posted by moptop

What the media fails to recondize is families were broken by the illegals coming to the usa in the first place no where have I ever seen or heard of a whole family sneeking across the boarder at one time!

Quit expecting american citizens to pick up the slack for people who think they can break the law by coming here...

Illegals are the current liberal media's darlings. Don't expect objective reporting. ************************************************** ********************************
Americans first in this magnificent country

American jobs for American workers

Fair trade, not free trade