COMMENTARY : THUMBS DOWN ON BORDER FLICK
http://images.townnews.com/nctimes.c...01-nctimes.gif
Thumbs down on border flick
By: BRIGID BRETT - for the North County Times
Thursday, December 13, 2007
http://images.townnews.com/nctimes.c...mugs/brett.gif
The recently opened American Spirit Theater at Escondido Charter High School is beautiful ---- it could be a wonderful addition to the community. You'd think that as a parent of two kids who thrived at ECHS I'd have felt a sense of pride, sitting on those comfortable seats, breathing in that still new smell. But my experience was quite the opposite.
It all started when I heard that the school had rented out the theater for a screening of a documentary called "Border" , presented by radio talk show host Roger Hedgecock and endorsed by various Minutemen groups. When I questioned the director of the school, Dennis Snyder, about supporting a film promoted by aggressively anti-immigrant individuals and racist groups, he disagreed with my assessment of the Minutemen and said he'd seen the film and thought it was "very good, educational and worth seeing." He said I should see it for myself before passing judgment. I agreed.
Roger Hedgecock is the former San Diego mayor who was forced from office in the 1980s after being found guilty of 13 felony convictions related to improper campaign contributions. In a deal with prosecutors, he eventually pleaded guilty to one misdemeanor conspiracy charge. He was in the lobby of the theater, signing copies of his new spiral-bound book "The 2008 Conservative Voter's Field Guide: Immigration."
He welcomed the audience before the film, announcing that it had no agenda and was simply a portrayal of the truth. The editor of the film then spoke, repeating the non-agenda, fair-and- balanced message multiple times. Did I mention that the subtitle of "Border" is: "A Man, His Dog and the End of America"?
The agenda of this film is blatantly clear: to scare the (insert expletive) out of you and make you think that unless you support the Minutemen, their border activities and the full-scale military protection of the border, Americans are doomed to a future of crime, filth, disease, hospital closures, rapists, drug dealers, unemployment and people who hate the American flag. The Minutemen were portrayed as golden heroes on horseback: saving lives, hunting down the bad guys, and bringing goodwill and security to all. And Chris Wilcox, the co-founder of the Minuteman Civil Defense Corps, was the star.
A film with a fair-and-balanced agenda would have included the multiple ways that illegal immigrants have contributed to the economy of this country. But only the most alarming of statistics regularly flashed across the screen, eliciting gasps from the audience. One of them was attributed to both the U.S. State Department and the Department of Justice: "10,000 people lost their lives since 9/11 at the hands of illegal aliens." I spoke with representatives from both agencies and was told that they have no idea where these statistics came from. I intend to verify the others and suspect that most are inaccurate.
According to hate crime statistics published annually by the FBI (I found them on the Web site of the Southern Poverty Law Center) anti-Latino hate crimes rose by almost 35 percent between 2003 and 2006. In California, the state with the largest population of Latinos in the country, anti-Latino hate crimes almost doubled in the same period. It is films like this that fuel the kind of fear leading to hate.
Valley Center resident Brigid Brett is a freelance columnist for the North County Times. Contact her at brigidbrett@aol.com.
http://www.nctimes.com/articles/2007/12 ... ogcomments