ESCONDIDO MAN FORMS CITY'S MINUTEMAN BRIGADE
Escondido man forms city's Minutemen Brigade
By: SARAH WILKINS and JO MORELAND - Staff Writers
NORTH COUNTY TIMES
FEBRUARY 1, 2007
ESCONDIDO ---- A newly formed group of anti-illegal immigration protesters has begun rallying at a popular hiring site in the central part of the city with the intent of curbing the hiring of illegal immigrants and decreasing problems they say the immigrants cause.
Escondido resident David Cline formed the Escondido Minutemen Brigade ---- an offshoot of the San Diego Minutemen, a prominent anti-illegal immigration group ---- in December, and has since regularly gathered with supporters at a hiring site along Quince Street between Mission and Washington avenues to wave American flags, hand out fliers and answer questions from passers-by.
The Escondido Minutemen work in association with the San Diego Minutemen, a group that in the last year has protested at day-labor sites and promoted legislation that targets illegal immigration. However, Cline said the new group operates separately in response to problems that occur specifically in Escondido.
The Escondido City Council passed an ordinance last year that would have barred landlords from renting to illegal immigrants. That ordinance was later dropped, but the council reaffirmed its opposition to illegal immigration in January by approving a resolution that asks the federal government for permission to inquire into residents' immigration status and handle illegal immigration problems locally.
"We want to move illegals out of Escondido," said Cline, 60, adding that his group hopes to halt hiring at the Quince Street location and then move on to other sites. Once the group accomplishes that goal, he said, he hopes to help others start up Minutemen groups in their areas.
But for now, Cline said, Escondido is his first priority.
At the protest Wednesday, Cline and his wife set up their Escondido Minutemen post, including three large American flags, drawing questioning looks from some of the day laborers and angry words from several of them. "Stop illegal aliens who murder police and civilians," one sign said.
"We're not so much against the illegals as the people who hire them," Cline said at the rally. "We're not targeting any of them. We're targeting the people who hire them. It's illegal to hire them."
Though Cline, an Escondido resident of 25 years, said many people are supportive of his work, the protests have rankled some immigrants rights activists.
Oceanside attorney Claudia Smith, a longtime activist and director of the California Rural Legal Assistance Border Project who attended the protest Wednesday morning, said that most of the men are hired for occasional home labor, and that such hiring isn't illegal.
"You are not required to verify employment authorization" for casual, unscheduled day hiring, she said.
Still, the protests so far have been mostly peaceful, Escondido police Sgt. John Russo said after Wednesday's gathering.
"They (the Minutemen) call us ahead of time and overall it's been real mild," Russo said. Officers are not assigned to monitor the protests, he said, but they are made aware of the times they take place.
Cline, a former auto service manager who is now working to become a flight instructor, said he first became involved with the Minutemen six months ago because of what he described as a decline in the quality of life for those who live in the city.
"Wherever you go in Escondido, you see illegals," Cline said. "I've seen crime increase in Escondido dramatically. ... After a while, enough is enough."
Al Rench, a 60-year-old Escondido resident and local Minutemen member, said he sees what he describes as more illegal immigrants in his city than in other North County cities.
"We feel cheated, we feel we're supporting them," he said.
Rench said he is particularly concerned about young Latino women he sees walking around with their children, who he believes are "anchor babies," a derisive term used to describe children born to illegal immigrant parents.
While many that the Minutemen target are from Mexico and elsewhere in Latin America, the group is not racist, Cline insists. Some Minutemen members are Latino, he added.
"I'm not against Hispanics, it's illegals ---- they need to come over here the correct way," he said. "If they just flood (over the border), California won't be the way that we know it."
Cline said his concern is that continued illegal immigration will tip economic scales, forcing middle-income residents to leave the area, which would "turn it into another Tijuana."
"Most people won't want it, they'll leave," Cline said. "The average income will drop dramatically. ... It won't be the Southern California we know today if amnesty starts."
Cline said he started the Escondido group because the larger Minutemen group was growing so big that Jeff Schwilk, the Oceanside resident that leads the group, "was getting overwhelmed."
Schwilk, who said his group includes about 375 people countywide, said that several other cities, including Encinitas, Vista, Oceanside and San Diego, have formed subgroups under the broader San Diego Minutemen organization.
"They're still affiliated, they just have their own separate groups to focus on that city," Schwilk said. "They work on their own cities and can keep tabs better that way."
Since being handed the reins in Escondido, the group has grown and Cline is "bent on continuing" his work, he said.
-- Contact staff writer Sarah Wilkins at (760) 761-4414 or swilkins@nctimes.com. Contact staff writer Jo Moreland at (760) 740-3524 or jmoreland@nctimes.com.
http://www.nctimes.com/articles/2007/02 ... _31_07.txt
http://www.nctimes.com/content/artic..._741_31_07.jpg
Workers at a day laborer hiring area in Escondido look at David Cline and his wife, of the new local Minutemen chapter, protesting their hiring Wednesday.
Comments On This Story
Note: Comments reflect the views of readers and not necessarily those of the North County Times or its staff.
Sandra in Escondido wrote on January 31, 2007 11:24 PM:" One sign says "Stop illegal aliens who murder police and civilians," and the next thing he says is were not targeting any of them. We're targeting the people who hire them. Please make up your mind either you want to stop the police and civilian murdering illegal aliens or you want to stop people from hiring them. Make up you minds. I think this group is a little disorganized if they do not even know what there own agenda is. What about this statement "Wherever you go in Escondido, you see illegals," Cline said. "I've seen crime increase in Escondido dramatically. ... After a while, enough is enough." So how do we know who is illegal? Do we determine that by the color of their skin? Do we determine that based on how many children they have? Do we determine that based on the clothes they wear? I am just confused and perhaps one of these non racist people can explain this strange phenomenon to me. I can say one thing for sure crime will increase if they continue to keep these men from working because if I were them and I was not allowed to work I would do whatever it takes to survive. How ridiculous that these people have nothing better to do than to push people into criminal activity. Oh I forgot "illegal aliens just come here to steal, rape and murder does that statement sound familiar Mr. Cline. I sorry but I am ashamed of your actions and I wish you would not taint the American Flag by flying it at your hate party. Oh frankly I do not care if some members of the mm group are Latinos your racist comments made in this article say it all. "
John wrote on January 31, 2007 11:33 PM:"Kudos to Mr. Cline who, with the exception of the sign that reads "stop ilegal immigrants who murder police and civilians," seems to be genuinely concerned about the legitimate problems associated with illegals and not merely racist against Mexicans. Too often, out of either legitimate bigotry or lack of speaking ability, Minutemen make comments that characterize themselves as being opposed to anyone who's brown or exhibits latino culture. This is pitiful. Mr. Cline's comments about targeting those who hire illegals (as opposed to other Minutemen who would stoop lower and would blame even legal latino immigrants for society's woes) renews my faith that there are at least some minutemen who observe what they preach. I only hope this is really the case. "
Senior Resident wrote on January 31, 2007 11:54 PM:"Congratulations Dave....I appreciate what you're trying to do and I totally support you. Hopefully you and your followers can somehow make a difference. Escondido is looking more like Tijuana every day and someone needs to do something about it. If there are no jobs for the illegals, then maybe they'll go someplace else, hopefully National City where they are welcomed. Better there than here."
Add Your Comments or Letter to the Editor
http://www.nctimes.com/articles/2007/02 ... _31_07.txt