Thread: Raleigh N&O Editorial: Reasons to Stay

http://www.newsobserver.com/579/story/469988.html

Editorial: Published: Aug 12, 2006 12:30 AM
Modified: Aug 12, 2006 06:33 AM

Reasons to stay

Granted, Noellie Nouanounou of Fuquay-Varina lied on U.S. immigration papers. And the Republic of Congo native does not have legal permission to live in the United States. But as recounted in an N&O story this week, deporting her would fragment a healthy family. A rational government policy on immigration ought to take factors such as that into account.

Immigration enforcement understandably has been toughened in the face of the terrorist threat, but Nouanounou clearly isn't a terrorist. She arrived here legally in 1995, accompanying her grandmother on a trip to Cary. In her hometown, she had been assaulted by militiamen.

She disclosed that incident to U.S. authorities when she sought permanent status. They denied her request, saying the assault was random, not because of political or ethnic ties, and therefore she was not entitled to asylum.

In desperation, out of legitimately perceived fear of returning home or simply because she wanted so badly to stay here, Nouanounou altered medical records to indicate that the assault had been worse than it was.

But she didn't go underground, and in fact she later formally reapplied for legal status. That was when her past caught up with her, including the altered reports. She now is in an Alabama jail awaiting deportation.

Nouanounou naturally doesn't want to be separated from three children, ages 5, 4 and 1, born in the United States and thus American citizens, and her Congo-born husband who is in the U.S. legally. She could, of course, take her family back to Congo with her, but like nearly all foreigners who elbow their way into the U.S. by any means necessary, Nouanounou seeks a better life, for her children and herself. Her native land is poor and dangerous.

The immigration agency is on a push to deport more illegal residents, a reasonable policy in light of terrorist plots and also the number of illegal immigrants from Mexico.

Yet the campaign is complicated by the 3.2 million children who were born in the U.S. with at least one parent who is an illegal immigrant, according to a 2005 estimate by the Pew Hispanic Center.

Those Americans can end up being unfairly punished. Enlightened laws ought to have a modest amount of flexibility so that people like Nouanounou -- who aren't violent criminals, who have stable homes, and whose children are American citizens -- aren't just automatically shipped back where they came from while children suffer.

All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be published, broadcast or redistributed in any manner.

A crime is a crime is a crime. She came here illegaly and is still illegal. Deport her back to her home country along with the three children she has born on US soil to take advantage of anchor baby nonesense.

Yet the campaign is complicated by the 3.2 million children who were born in the U.S. with at least one parent who is an illegal immigrant, according to a 2005 estimate by the Pew Hispanic Center

Those kids can go with their parents. That's just another lame excuse to stay in the US. Many Americans take their children out of this country and the illegals can take theirs too. Kids or no kids, they need to be deported. Just like they are in France!

Dixie

Here is another article on this subject. I still say deport. This illegal has taken advantage of US citizens.

These parents should have thoroughly looked into any consequences before they birthed three young children. American taxpayers should not have to suffer the burdens of those who have children they cannot afford. In addition, this Planet is overwhelmed with overpopulation. Let's let those who birth in the extreme and birth infants they cannot afford to raise WITHOUT welfare and/or ESCAPING to a richer nation, know that they cannot get away with it.

I've known so many Americans, and I am one, who delayed child birth purposely, reduced the number of children desired, or decided not to have any at all because we could not afford it.

What gives citizens of foreign countries the rights to come here and have a gadzillion children???

http://www.newsobserver.com/719/story/469063.html

Crackdown on immigrants splits family

With his wife, Noellie, in jail and facing deportation to the Republic of Congo, Gervais Nouanounou has sought her uncle's help to care for the couple's children, from left, Jason Alvin, 5, Ochlie, 4, and Gervelie, 1.
Staff Photo by Leslie Barbour

Toby Coleman, Staff Writer

The past found Noellie Nouanounou as she held her 1-year-old daughter in an immigration interview room in Charlotte.
She handed over her diapered child to her husband, Gervais, and was escorted away to face a seven-year-old deportation order.

"They said, 'Even though you have children, you're going in,'" said Nouanounou (new-AH-new-new), a native of the Republic of Congo in West Africa. She has three American-born children, ages 5, 4 and 1.

Across the nation, parents like Noellie Nouanounou of Fuquay-Varina are missing story times, baths and other family rituals because they have been caught in the government's stepped-up efforts to expel illegal immigrants. Those left behind must decide whether to continue their lives in the United States or uproot their children, who are U.S. citizens.

Nobody keeps track of how many illegal immigrants who are parents are deported each year, but researchers suspect the number is growing because deportations overall are rising, said Randy Capps of the Urban Institute, a Washington think tank.

Millions are at risk. The Pew Hispanic Center estimated in 2005 that 3.2 million American-citizen children have at least one illegal immigrant parent.

The situation has inspired some in Congress to rethink the constitutional guarantee of citizenship to everyone born in the United States, regardless of parentage. Researchers wonder what will happen to children who lose parents to deportation.

"I don't think anybody knows what the long-term implications are," Capps said. "But they're not likely to be good."

Noellie Nouanounou has missed the first steps of her 1-year-old daughter, Gervelie, since she has been in jail awaiting her fate.

It may be among many lost moments. "I will miss the chance to see them when they grow up or see them when they graduate or see them do most of that stuff," she said in a phone interview from the Etowah County jail in Gadsden, Ala. "I am worried for them."

Nouanounou, 30, has nobody to blame but herself. Years ago, she hobbled her petition for asylum by altering medical records. In March 1999, an immigration judge ordered her deported to Republic of Congo, a small country of about 3.7 million snuggled alongside its larger cousin, the Democratic Republic of Congo.

Immigration authorities say it is time for Nouanounou to honor the order to leave the country -- family or no.

"She has a final order of removal issued and sustained by an immigration judge," said Marc Raimondi, a spokesman for Immigration and Customs Enforcement. "She's had her day in court."

Immigration judges can cancel deportation orders, but they rarely do. Last year, judges canceled or suspended deportations of about 4,000 illegal immigrants. In comparison, they told more than 220,000 to leave.

Assault by militiamen

Nouanounou is in trouble, said her husband, Gervais, a legal, permanent resident also from the Republic of Congo.

"I keep thinking about why is this happening," he said. "Why this kind of experience? Why we have three kids. Why this had to happen."

Noellie Nouanounou came to America in 1995 to escort her grandmother to her uncle's Cary home. With her, she carried the memories of being assaulted by militiamen in her hometown.

She stayed, hoping the U.S. government would shelter her from her country's political unrest. In her application for asylum, she said the assault showed the danger she would face if she returned to Brazzaville, the Congolese capital.

It didn't work. Immigration officials wrote that they could not give her asylum because the assault "appears to have been a random act of violence, not one directed at [her] because of membership in any particular group," according to documents provided by Nouanounou's family.

She appealed the ruling. While she waited for an immigration judge to decide, she said, she tried to bolster her case by altering medical records to make it look as if she had been complaining for years about aftereffects of the assault.

It's not clear how extensively Nouanounou altered the records. The government's file on her asylum case is secret, and her lawyer, Cynthia Aziz of Charlotte, said she could not discuss the proceedings because of attorney-client confidentiality rules.

Once the judge learned what she had done, Nouanounou said, he rejected her asylum request.

"It was a stupid mistake," she said. Nouanounou says she spent the next few months waiting for a written deportation order but never got one. Immigration officials say it was issued in March 1999, according to documents provided by the family.

"I just supposed that a decision was not taken," she said. "I thought maybe we should just disregard."

So she stayed and, in August 1999, she became Mrs. Gervais Nouanounou.

Meeting leads to jail

She flew under the government's radar for years, even as she had kids, obtained a mortgage and learned to bake chocolate-chip cookies. After holding a series of jobs, she became a stay-at-home mom when her husband got a job working nights in a pharmaceutical company microbiology lab.

She said she did not hide. In 2001, she even announced her presence to immigration authorities by applying for legal residency, documents provided by the family show.

Nouanounou said she believed she was on the cusp of legal status. So she said she didn't fret when immigration authorities asked to meet with her last month -- until someone walked in and called her a fugitive.

Now she is in jail, unsure whether she will ever again set foot in her family's home.

Her kids know only that their mother is on a trip. Gervais tells them she will be home soon.

"Where is Mommy?" they asked at a recent dinner, according to David Mpongo, Noellie Nouanounou's uncle. "When is she coming home?"

"I don't know what I'm going to tell them," he said later.

Gervais Nouanounou knows he cannot follow his wife back home if she is deported. He doesn't want to raise their children in a land hobbled by political tumult, bandit militias and disease.

"Things are very terrible there," he said. "I know they're not going to make it in Africa."

But he cannot take care of the kids on his own. In the days after immigration authorities scooped up his wife, he sent them to stay at Mpongo's house on a Cary cul-de-sac. Nouanounou spent most of his time there, too.

Mpongo reminded him to eat and helped pay for Noellie Nouanounou's short but expensive collect calls from jail.

During a July 28 call, Ochlie, 4, took the phone and, at her mother's request, began singing.

"Fathers and mothers, the Bible is a mirror of life eternal forever," she sang in Kikongo, her mother's native tongue.

Nouanounou sobbed.

"Hey, look," her husband said after Ochlie finished. "We need to have hope and faith. Keep praying."

Staff writer Toby Coleman can be reached at 829-8937 or tcoleman@newsobserver.com.

In desperation, out of legitimately perceived fear of returning home or simply because she wanted so badly to stay here, Nouanounou altered medical records to indicate that the assault had been worse than it was.

Attempting to deceive the federal government my dear lady is fraud. Sorry, you're out of here!

Please, someone pass me a tissue.

It may be among many lost moments. "I will miss the chance to see them when they grow up or see them when they graduate or see them do most of that stuff," she said in a phone interview from the Etowah County jail in Gadsden, Ala. "I am worried for them."

Come on, let's be serious here. You and I both know your husband and children will join you in Congo. You've already been ordered to deport, so the crying to the newspapers won't do you any good - give it up. No husband that truely loves his wife would stay here while you were deported. The show is over, so quite attempting to gain sympathy through the media. Too bad you're not in Chicago, because the crying game actually works there.

Next look for the N&O to interview the children.