Updated
 February 27, 2012 2:23 PM

Are People Getting Dumber?
Debaters
Thinking in More Sophisticated Ways
James R. Flynn, author, "What Is Intelligence?"
Far from devolving, modern humans are getting smarter about applying logic to hypothetical situations.

　
Stupidity Is Funny, but It’s No Joke
Erin Jackson, stand-up comic
Without dumb people doing dumb things, I wouldn’t have anything to riff about. I'd love to have that problem.

　
To See Humans’ Progress, Zoom Out
Steven Pinker, author, "The Better Angels of Our Nature"
It’s easy to focus on the idiocies of the present and forget those of the past. A reality check shows we are improving.

　
The World Grows More Complex
Linda S. Gottfredson, sociologist, University of Delaware
Modern innovations make us feel dumber, because they add to the work our minds must do.

　
Smart Moments Don’t Go Viral
Ritch Duncan, staff writer, Dumb as a Blog
Online, the really dumb things that people do — even people of average intelligence — get amplified almost instantaneously.

　
If you turn on the TV, or flip through standardized tests, or spend a mindless hour on YouTube, it’s hard not to wonder: Is our species devolving? Are people getting dumber?
Read the Discussion »

Thinking in More Sophisticated Ways
　
James R. Flynn, an emeritus professor of politics at the University of Otago in New Zealand, is the author of "What Is Intelligence?: Beyond the Flynn Effect" and "Are We Getting Smarter? Rising IQ and the Twenty-First Century," forthcoming in August from Cambridge University Press.

Updated

February 27, 2012, 2:37 PM

On an IQ test, the average person today would be 30 points above his or her grandparents, so we are not getting any dumber. But are we smarter? That’s a more complicated idea. In fact, it’s the subject of my next book: "Are We Getting Smarter? Rising IQ and the Twenty-First Century."

I would prefer to say that our minds are 'more modern' than those of our ancestors.

If the question is "Do we have better brain potential at conception," or "Were our ancestors too stupid to deal with the concrete world of everyday life," the answer is no. If the question is "Do we live in a time that poses a wider range of cognitive problems than our ancestors encountered, and have we developed new cognitive skills and the kind of brain that can deal with them," the answer is yes.

I would prefer to say that our minds are "more modern" than those of our ancestors. Our ancestors lived in a world that was concrete and utilitarian. In 1900, schoolchildren were asked, "What are the capitals of the 46 states?" Today they are asked, "If rural representatives dominated a state legislature, where would they put the capital?" (The answer is that, because they hate big cities, they would put the state capital in Albany rather than New York City.) In other words, we take applying logic to hypothetical situations seriously, plus of course playing video games that take us into hypothetical and symbolic worlds.

As a result, we are better prepared to learn about science, which is all about the hypothetical and abstractions, and even to reason better about ethics. If you asked my father, "What if you woke up one day and were black," he would say that is ridiculous. But a modern racist would have to take the question seriously. He would have to say that black people are worthy of discrimination not simply because they are black, but because of some genetic taint.

Immediately, evidence enters the debate and takes it to a higher level.
Join
Room for Debate on Facebook and follow updates on twitter.com/roomfordebate.

Are People Getting Dumber? - Room for Debate - NYTimes.com