Results 1 to 4 of 4

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

  1. #1
    Senior Member florgal's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    North Carolina
    Posts
    3,386

    SEIU’s Post-Andy Stern Future (Why quit now?)

    SEIU’s Post-Andy Stern Future

    by Randy Shaw‚ Apr. 14‚ 2010

    0diggsdigg Review it on NewsTrust

    Andy Stern’s announcement that he is resigning as SEIU President was abrupt and unexpected. It leaves Anna Burger and Mary Kay Henry scrambling to win majority support on the Executive Board. While Stern groomed Burger as his successor, he leaves office without ensuring a smooth path for her election. And considering that Burger is more closely identified with Stern’s policies, the Executive Board may prefer to give the appearance of charting a new course by selecting Henry as the new President. Here’s my assessment of what Stern’s departure means for SEIU, its battles against UNITE HERE and NUHW, and for the rest of the labor movement.

    Why Stern Quit

    It’s been widely reported that Stern always planned to leave after the passage of health care legislation, even though his official position was that he would wait until after the 2012 SEIU Convention. But there are some curious aspects of Stern’s departure.

    First, it came suddenly, and the media picked up the story from an email sent by Dianne Sosne the head of an SEIU local in Seattle. Why would SEIU, which has the smoothest media operation in labor, allow word of its President’s surprise resignation to seep out through a staff email rather than an official announcement?

    Second, why would Stern quit only days after the verdict in SEIU’s civil lawsuit against NUHW? Even if his departure had nothing to do with the lawsuit, its timing supports arguments that SEIU’s lawsuit failed to achieve its goal, and that Stern no longer wished to be involved in the bitter and likely long-running California battle.

    Third, why would Stern quit without clearing a path for his successor? Both Anna Burger and Mary Kay Henry have been on the phone with Executive Board members seeking their support. While Burger remains the favorite, Stern’s successor will not be a quick, unanimous choice.

    Fourth, Stern announced his resignation after last week’s negotiating session with UNITE HERE failed to make progress (it was supposed to take two days but the second day was cancelled). The combination of the disappointing trial verdict against NUHW and Stern’s inability to resolve SEIU’s conflict with UNITE HERE may have led him to conclude that it was time for someone else to take over.

    There has long been talk about possible health issues, or Stern being connected to the Tyrone Freeman corruption scandal in Los Angeles, but there is no hard evidence that either was a factor.

    The bottom line: Stern was burned out, saw nothing on the immediate horizon that excited him, and decided he wanted out. He clearly prefers being a spokesperson for political issues to the day to day struggles of running a labor union, and expect him to stay politically involved.

    The Impact of Stern’s Departure

    Andy Stern’s personality dominated SEIU and helped build the union’s success. The fear and loyalty he engendered among staff, members and the media is not transferable.

    This likely means more open debate and internal dissent at SEIU, which can only help the union’s troubled relations with the broader labor movement. It will be easier for Stern’s successor to move SEIU back into the AFL-CIO (Change to Win was effectively killed after SEIU attacked ally UNITE HERE), and possibly easier to resolve SEIU’s conflict with UNITE HERE.

    Stern framed SEIU’s fight against UNITE HERE in personal terms, describing how he was fighting to protect his grandmother’s assets and legacy with the ILGWU. Of course, Stern ignored Raynor's depleting tens of millions of dollars in ILGWU assets after he took control of the union's real estate and other resources following a merger.

    Stern's close friendship with Raynor clearly clouded his judgment, plunging SEIU into a still ongoing politically and financially disastrous battle with UNITE HERE.

    Burger and Henry are not driven by such personal feelings, and are likely to view SEIU’s campaign against UNITE HERE strictly in terms of what is best for their union. Stern’s departure clearly encourages forces within SEIU who have long sought peace with UNITE HERE.

    SEIU v. NUHW

    Stern’s leaving also sends a message to SEIU-UHW members desperately trying to resist NUHW incursions. The message is that their leader has jumped ship, while Sal Rosselli---whom SEIU regularly and falsely accuses of dodging fights---is still around.

    That may sound harsh, but Stern was the one figure in SEIU that all members knew, and the one whose pronouncements were accepted without debate. Mary Kay Henry is known to workers, but lacks the charisma and sense of Washington DC power of Andy Stern.

    SEIU-UHW members have to be wondering what’s going on with their union, particularly after its $5-10 million lawsuit against NUHW failed to accomplish its goals.

    Mary Kay Henry testified at trial against NUHW, was centrally involved in the decision to place the SEIU-UHW in trusteeship, and is not about to consider making peace with Sal Rosselli (unconfirmed reports are that by August 2008 Henry was among those pledging to “destroyâ€

  2. #2
    Senior Member ReggieMay's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    5,527
    Maybe he's leaving SEIU for a job in the white house. I wouldn't be surprised.
    "A Nation of sheep will beget a government of Wolves" -Edward R. Murrow

    Join our efforts to Secure America's Borders and End Illegal Immigration by Joining ALIPAC's E-Mail Alerts network (CLICK HERE)

  3. #3
    Senior Member florgal's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    North Carolina
    Posts
    3,386
    Quote Originally Posted by ReggieMay
    Maybe he's leaving SEIU for a job in the white house. I wouldn't be surprised.
    That was the first thing I thought when I heard he was leaving SEIU.

  4. #4
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    TEXAS - The Lone Star State
    Posts
    16,941
    Quote Originally Posted by florgal
    Quote Originally Posted by ReggieMay
    Maybe he's leaving SEIU for a job in the white house. I wouldn't be surprised.
    That was the first thing I thought when I heard he was leaving SEIU.

    he had better not be appointed to any federal job. that would mean we the taxpayer would have to pay his salary, pension and who knows what else. after screwing the american people over on health care. that was what he wanted and with the help of the jerk in office, he got it

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •