Thread: Why California Is Running Dry, 60 MINUTES

Dec. 27, 2009

Why California Is Running Dry

60 Minutes: Three-Year Drought Is Bringing A Decades-Long Fight Over Water To A Head

A three-year drought in California is bringing a decades-long fight over water to a head, forcing tough choices. Lesley Stahl reports.

Video Web Extra: The Water Diet

California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger says his state needs to take a dieter's approach to water consumption.
(CBS/AP)

(CBS) Water is in short supply. You don't have to go to Africa or the Middle East to see how much the planet is running dry. Just go to California, where, after three years of drought, dozens of towns and cities have imposed mandatory water rationing and a half million acres in the country's agricultural breadbasket are lying fallow.

Arnold Schwarzenegger, the action hero governor, has thrust himself into the fray by requiring towns and cities across the state to reduce their water use by 20 percent over ten years. That means less water to drink, to bathe in, and to water the lawn.

Governor Schwarzenegger only has a year left in office, and he's well aware of the old saying "Whisky is for drinking, water is for fighting."

Web Extra: The Water Diet

"People have died over water. You know, movies have been made about the wars of water in California," Gov. Schwarzenegger told 60 Minutes correspondent Lesley Stahl.

"Chinatown," Stahl remarked.

"Exactly," Schwarzenegger replied. "So water has been one of those issues."

It's one of those issues that is pitting Californians against each other for every last drop.

Schwarzenegger says his state is in crisis. "We've been in crisis for quite some time because we're now 38 million people and not anymore 18 million people like we were in the late 60s. So it developed into a battle between environmentalists and farmers and between the south and the north and between rural and urban. And everyone has been fighting for the last four decades about water."

He took us to the San Luis Reservoir in California's farm country.

"Everything that you see here was all full of water," he told Stahl.

He showed us how desperate things are: the drought that has affected the western part of the country has left its mark there - water levels are only half what they should be. It's like a bathtub ring, showing the previous water level.

"It's a disastrous situation and we got to do something about that very quickly," he told Stahl.

The reservoir is a key part of the water system that has kept southern California - and one of the most productive agricultural basins in the world - green and arable, until now.

"It looks like sand. It looks like a desert, actually," Stahl remarked, while talking with Todd Allen, a wheat, cotton and cantaloupe farmer in California's Central Valley.

"This right here is 150 acres, and there hasn't been anything planted on it," Allen pointed out.

"This is all fallow out here?" Stahl asked.

"Yes," Allen replied. "Nothing has been grown on this, this year."

And because of that, his bank cut off his line of credit.

"You know, I've got a wife and kids," he said. "The thought of bankruptcy is something…I don't think I could deal with that."

But he doesn't blame his troubles on the drought. He blames the environmentalists who sued under the Endangered Species Act to protect a tiny little fish, the Delta smelt, that was being killed off by California's main water pumps.

A federal judge ordered that the pumps be turned down, and Allen's taps almost ran dry.

"When you can put the needs of a two-inch fish above me and my family and that thing could potentially bankrupt me, I got a serious problem with that," Allen told Stahl.

"Here's the way I've heard it described: fish versus farms," she remarked.

"Well I would say I'm at the bottom of the food chain. I even told Schwarzenegger to put all of us farmers out here on the California Endangered Species Act. Because that's what I feel. I feel like I'm being punished, and I haven't done a darn thing wrong," Allen said.
(CBS) Allen has joined an unlikely political coalition with usually conservative farmers and their usually liberal Latino farm workers.

They and Schwarzenegger want the federal government to find a way to undo the judge's order that has been reducing the water flow to save the fish.

Asked if he thinks they should just let the smelt go extinct, Schwarzenegger said, "No. …I think there is a better way of going."

He doesn't want to tarnish his environmental credentials - he's known as "the green governor." So he's trying to have it both ways.

Asked if he can have it all, he told Stahl, "Absolutely, you can have it all."

"Save the smelt?" she asked.

"It's just you got to recognize that it is a very, very complicated issue," Schwarzenegger replied.

Stahl spoke to Jeffrey Mount, founder of the Center for Watershed Sciences at the University of California, Davis. He says the smelt were once "incredibly abundant," but that very few of them are left."

Mount says that three quarters of the water shortages are caused by the drought, not the fish, and he has a message for the farmers: "Don't plant crops that have to have water every year. So some of the mistakes that farmers are making in that system is they're planting crops that can't be sustained in periods of severe drought. And Lesley, if there's one takeaway to have here, is the future for California is going to be dealing with scarcity. We have to adapt to basically chronic scarcity."

He does admit that the timing of the judge's order, in the midst of the drought, has made things worse.

"I mean, of all times to come along and try to save a little fish that big. People don't understand. They don't get it," Stahl remarked.

"Well, I wish they would ask beyond the little fish, because the little fish is essentially your bellwether. It's telling you, you have an ecosystem which is in dramatic decline," Mount said.

He points to the state's salmon population, which is so low that commercial fishing has been shut down for two years.

Asked what has gone wrong, Mount told Stahl, "We can't do it sustainably. You cannot currently meet the demand. Nowhere else on the planet can you point to a place which relies, for their water supply system, on an estuary."

An immense estuary, the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta is where the state's main rivers meet the sea. The best way to get a sense of how vast it is is from the sky.

"This is it. This is the delta," Schwarzenegger told Stahl during an aerial tour of the estuary.

"The home of the famous Delta smelt that all the controversy seems to have bubbled up over," she remarked.

"Well it's the home of the smelt and all kinds of other species that people have been fighting over. And it's all happening right in this area," Schwarzenegger explained.

(CBS) Stahl and the governor flew over what is the hub of California's water system, over a web of channels and islands through which river water flows from the north and is pumped into a highway of aqueducts and on to the $25-billion crop industry and to cities like Los Angeles.

"The delta was never meant to take this water through," Schwarzenegger said.

This water system through the delta, with its series of dams and reservoirs, is as big of a problem as is water scarcity. The system hasn't been expanded since the 1960s. Hard to believe, it is held together by 1,100 miles of crumbling levees and it sits next to five major earthquake fault lines.

"It's brittle and its fragile and it kind of teeters on the edge of failure," Jeffrey Mount told Stahl.

He showed us a computer simulation of how catastrophic it would be if the levees broke.

"So blue means drinkable water, orange is completely salty water. It literally pulls water out of San Francisco Bay, brings the salt all the way to the south delta here where the pumps are and by now you've shut off the water supply to 25 million people," Mount explained.

The simulation is based on what happens during an earthquake, but the levees are in such bad shape they've been collapsing on their own. The last major failure was on a sunny day in 2004.

"Anybody listening to you is thinking Katrina. They're thinking New Orleans…," Stahl remarked.

"This is our Katrina," Mount said. "And any rational look at it says, 'That's not acceptable.'"

Schwarzenegger has made fixing the delta a high priority and last month got sweeping water legislation passed, including an $11 billion bond for next fall's ballot that would pay for new dams to increase the state's ability to store water.

The governor also wants to build a canal that would re-route water around the delta to save the estuary and expedite the flow south. The canal will cost billions more.

"Look at the economic crisis that we're facing right now. Your state alone is facing a $21 billion deficit. It's said the canal alone will be a bigger project than the Panama Canal. I mean, this is going to be huge," Stahl said.

"Some people make it sound bigger. And they put numbers on it which is not the case. But the whole thing is, without any doubt if you put it all together, it's a $40-billion plus project," Schwarzenegger said.

"Well, you're going to go to the public here in California. This could fizzle, couldn’t it, if they don’t pass it?" Stahl asked. "I know you don't want to be pessimistic."

"Let me give you something positive. No, let me just give you something positive," Schwarzenegger said.

"Be analytical," Stahl said.

"Yes. I'm just trying to tell you that we need [to] educate the people…people like to rebuild. They like to build new dams. They like to rebuild and build California and make sure that it stays the number one place in the world," he replied.
(CBS) But time is running out for farmers like Stuart Woolf, who runs his family's big almond and tomato business.

He's deciding which of his almond trees to chop down and shred. He has destroyed 130,000 so far, worth, he says, $18 million.

He told Stahl he has to tear down the trees because of the water problem.

Once felled, they're fed into what is known as a tub grinder. "It can grind about five mature almond trees in a minute. And these trees, a tree of this size would normally take about 20 years to grow. And within 20 seconds, sawdust," Woolf explained.

What is happening is going to have an impact, he says, because half the country's fruits and nuts come from this area.

"We will find higher food prices, maybe less selection from California. But these crops may very well come from other regions of the world," Woolf said.

"But so far the average consumer in California and all across the country, we haven't felt it," Stahl remarked.

"No. I don't think we've felt this impact yet. But it will come," he predicted.

Where the impact is already felt is in the farm communities where unemployment has reached as high as 40 percent. Farm hands who used to work in the nation's breadbasket are now standing in breadlines. Some of the vegetables have been sent from, of all places, China.

"There are people who say the southern part of the state is thirsty. They say that some of these farms should just go out of business. That they take too much water, and people need that water," Stahl told Schwarzenegger.

"Yes. You know. Of course, I totally understand that. But I look at the overall picture again. I tell you I want it all. I love our farms," the governor replied.

He told Stahl it is realistic. "Anything is realistic. It doesn't mean because it's a desert that we cannot go and bring water in here and start growing things. All we have to do is deliver water and then we can grow anything we want."

So much for the idea that the state is entering an age of scarcity.

Schwarzenegger, who first became famous for pumping iron, wants to be remembered for pumping water back into California.

Asked why he decided to take on this issue, Schwarzenegger said, "It's easy to just push things off and I don't like the idea of kicking the can down the alley."

"You could have so easily done that?" Stahl asked.

"Yes, but I mean I like, remember, I come from the sports background where you kind of welcome resistance you welcome kind of you know, torture sometimes," he replied. "And all of those kind of things, you know, because that's the only way you get to be a champion."

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2009/12/ ... bsCarousel

Food Facts

California has been the number one food and agricultural producer in the United States for more than 50 consecutive years.

More than half the nation's fruit, nuts, and vegetables come from here.

California is the nation's number one dairy state.

California's leading commodity is milk and cream. Grapes are second.

California's leading export crop is almonds.

Nationally, products exclusively grown (99% or more) in California include almonds, artichokes, dates, figs, kiwifruit, olives, persimmons, pistachios, prunes, raisins, clovers, and walnuts.

From 70 to 80% of all ripe olives are grown in California.

California is the nation's leading producer of strawberries, averaging 1.4 billion pounds of strawberries or 83% of the country's total fresh and frozen strawberry production. Approximately 12% of the crop is exported to Canada, Mexico, United Kingdom, Hong Kong and Japan primarily. The value of the California strawberry crop is approximately $700 million with related employment of more than 48,000 people.

California produces 25% of the nation's onions and 43% of the nation's green onions.

Gilroy, California, "Garlic Capitol of the World."

http://www.beachcalifornia.com/californ ... facts.html

VIDEO

California: Running Dry
(See what the area in dispute looks like)
http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=6027412n

Web Extra: The Water Diet
http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=6027354n

California leads the nation in the production of fruits and vegetables, including carrots, lettuce, onions, broccoli, tomatoes, strawberries, and almonds.

The state's most valuable crops are grapes, cotton, flowers, and oranges

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_are_the_ ... California

And how many illegals live there now? Gee let me think, if you don't have the strain on the resources they tend to go further. I know droughts cause problems, but if there isn't as much of a drain on them, they last longer and the pinch isn't as bad.

San Diego County is the Avocado Capital of the U.S.,
producing 60% of all the avocados grown in California. There are about 7000 avocado groves in . . .
www.avocado.org/about/fun-facts - Cached - Similar

Avocado -
Avocados consumed in the US are grown almost exclusively in California and Florida. . . .
www.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avocado - Cached - Similar

Originally Posted by Hylander_1314

And how many illegals live there now? Gee let me think, if you don't have the strain on the resources they tend to go further. I know droughts cause problems, but if there isn't as much of a drain on them, they last longer and the pinch isn't as bad.

It's a little more complicated than that.

California Water Wars

The California Water Wars describes the disputes between Los Angeles and the Owens Valley in California over water rights. The disputes stem from Los Angeles' location in a semi-arid area and the availability of water from Sierra Nevada runoff in the Owens Valley.

Early views of Owens Valley water diversion

In 1833 Joseph Reddeford Walker led the first known expedition into the area that would later be called the Owens Valley in central California. Walker saw that the valley’s soil conditions were inferior to those on the other side of the Sierra Nevada range and that runoff from the mountains was absorbed into the arid desert ground. After the United States gained control of California in 1848 the first public land survey conducted by A.W. Von Schmidt from 1855 to 1856 was an initial step in securing government control of the valley. Von Schmidt reported that the valley's soil was not good for agriculture except for the land near streams, and incorrectly stated that the "Owens Valley [was] worthless to the White Man". The potential of the valley, however, was seen in 1859 by Army Captain J.W. Davidson who came in contact with the Paiute Indians and their use of irrigation ditches to divert water from streams. The first settlers downplayed the agriculture achievements of the Paiutes as a validation for forcing them off of their land. Pioneers claimed that the Paiute Indians diverted water to natural vegetation, not crops. Settlers failed to see the significance of the act of diverting water itself, an act that would devastate the Owens Valley in the twentieth century.

Early settlement: land use, water diversion and speculation
Many settlers came to the area for the promise of riches from mining. Once pioneers reached the Owens Valley this dream faded and they took up farming and raising livestock instead. The Homestead Act of 1862 gave pioneers five years to claim and take title of their land for a small filing fee and a charge of $1.25 per acre. The Homestead Act limited the land an individual could own to 160 acres (64.7 ha) in order to create small farms. The Swampland Act of 1850 allowed public lands deemed as swamp and overflow land to be turned over to the state. In 1873 Josiah Earl, the registrar of the newly created Independence Land District, set out to use the Swampland Act to acquire land for the state. He declared that about one third of the valley to be swamp or overflow land, of which more than 40% was already occupied by settlers. This action by the Land District drew so much protest that Earl abandoned his plan, effectively postponing large-scale land speculation in the Owens Valley.

The amount of public land settled by the late 1870s and early 1880s was still relatively small. The Desert Land Act of 1877 allowed individuals to acquire more area, up to 640 acres (259.0 ha), in hopes of drawing more settlers by giving them enough land to make their settlement and land expenses worthwhile, but included no residency requirements.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Water_Wars

I understand that it is more complex than that. The reality is though, especially out west where water can be more valuable than gold, is that the resources can only support so much population, and if it goes over that and continually pressures the land and water supply, then every year will give diminishing returns due to lack of situations.

It's like the Denver area, even though this last year was a bumper for water from all the rain, yet my ex was telling me they were still on water rationing. The land and the resources can only support so much before it becomes detrimental to the area, and the society. Lack of resources is what can cause terrible problems, and there is never any relief from it as the proper course to remedy the issue isn't taken. Mostly becaise politicians only think of the tax dollars they will collect from a burgeoning populace.

But I do understand the big picture. Trying to type it out would take too long, so short is how I like to keep it, or else it's a bore to read.

Also, I don't remember the agreement, but the Governor of Colorado back in I think 1912 signed a good portion of the snowmelt water to Arizona so it prevented dams being built to provide water for Colorado, which has helped indirectly to control population growth as it's harder territoy from natural sparsity of towns and the mountainous region.

About 40 million people get water from the Colorado. Studies show it's drying up.