Wisconsin residents blame fracking for a boom in sand mining facilities

ByDEAN REYNOLDS CBS NEWS April 18, 2014, 7:11 PM
Wisconsin residents blame fracking for a boom in sand mining facilities

ARCADIA, Wis. -- In Wisconsin, residents are having an emotional debate over the fuel-drilling technique known as "fracking," in which a sand mixture is blasted underground to extract oil and gas from rock.

Rural Wisconsin is rich in a special kind of sand used in fracking, and mining companies are lining up to get to it. But now, some residents are lining up to stop them.

At a packed town hall meeting in Arcadia, Wis., representatives of the mining company All-Energy sought to assure residents that a proposed 725-acre mine posed no risk.

http://cbsnews2.cbsistatic.com/hub/i...noldsgrab1.jpgThe town hall meeting in Arcadia, Wis.
CBS

A mining advocate said, "Six seconds a week is the amount of blasting we're going to do."But the audience was not convinced.

An opponent of the proposed mine said, "Why are we taking top-producing farmland and destroying it to produce -- to get sand out?"

Maybe if it was one mine the response would not have been as emotional. But the idyllic farmland of West Central Wisconsin has been transformed by 135 sand mining facilities -- up from five just a few years ago.

http://cbsnews1.cbsistatic.com/hub/i...noldsgrab3.jpgAn aerial view of a sand mining operation.
CBS

Oil and gas companies need the special crush-resistant sand to probe for fossil fuels in the process known as fracking.Resident Brenda Tabor-Adams said, "The trucks drive past here, and there's sand on the road, there's sand on the ditch, so I do get a lot in my house."

http://cbsnews1.cbsistatic.com/hub/i...noldsgrab6.jpg
Brenda Tabor-Adams
CBS

All that blowing sand is a health concern for Tabor-Adams. Her farm is surrounded by four sand mines."After now dealing with it for a couple of years, I am starting to get some respiratory issues," she said.

"Wheezing. It'll wake me up at night."

Professor Crispin Pierce of the University of Wisconsin at Eau Claire has been sampling the air near 11 local plants and found elevated levels of dust with crystalline silica, which can cause cancer. He said, "Like asbestos, it's a component of these small bits of dust that's particularly dangerous and damaging."But while the mining boom here has created concern, it's also created nearly 3,000 jobs.

Rich Budinger, president of the Wisconsin Industrial Sand Association, which runs 10 mines, said, "The growth in this industry -- as long as it's done responsibly -- is an excellent, awesome opportunity for Wisconsin."

He told CBS News that if the mining companies just follow existing safety regulations, the threat from blowing sand will dissipate.

http://cbsnews1.cbsistatic.com/hub/i...noldsgrab8.jpg
Rich Budinger, president of the Wisconsin Industrial Sand Association
CBS

Budinger added, "Water wagons are constantly watering down the roads, we have sprinkler systems on our stockpiles."Still, over the past two years, Wisconsin's Department of Natural Resources has issued 22 citations for non-compliance with environmental regulations to 21 different mining companies.

And while the county board eventually rejected All-Energy's plant for Arcadia, elsewhere in the state there are few signs of a slowdown with 51 new mines already in the works.

http://www.cbsnews.com/news/fracking...rilling-booms/

1. Glenwood City, Wis., council OKs early phase of frac sand mine Pioneer Press-Apr 15, 2014 Glenwood City Mayor John Larson, center, and city council members Scott Shone and Dave Graese listen to Charlotte Heimer, foreground, ...

2. https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/i...fngglxxoUpgZKU The fight over frac sand mining in Wisconsin Isthmus Daily Page-Mar 22, 2014 I was aware of Wisconsin's frac sand mining boom. The number of permitted or operational mines and processing facilities rose from 10 in 2010 ...

3. https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/i...VyZl4akZyG3z44 The fight over frac sand mining Isthmus-Mar 20, 2014 I was aware of Wisconsin's frac sand mining boom. The number of permitted or operational mines and processing facilities rose from 10 in 2010 ...

4. https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/i...ldb0Capn8xshoM Frac sand mines credited for rising, dropping property values WisconsinWatch.org-Mar 31, 2014 In the three years since Tunnel City area residents found themselves at the forefront of Wisconsin's frac sand mining boom, economic variations ...

5. https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/i...OKcjB65G1GT0zs How the Wisconsin Winter Puts a Chill on Texas Oil Drilling Wall Street Journal (blog)-Mar 31, 2014 Sand mines have been popping up all over Wisconsin because the state is home to a special variety of white silica that has strong, perfectly ...

6. Letter: Greed, ignorance drive sand-mining boom La Crosse Tribune-4 hours ago The Driftless Area of Wisconsin's beautiful uniqueness, its specialness is because of these incredible bluffs! You will find them nowhere else.

7. https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/i...db_IOZm0hSZxb8 Fracking sand spurs grain-like silos for rail transport FuelFix (blog)-12 hours ago The sand is needed to keep open cracks in the shale after water and ... in the region and sand mines in Wisconsin, Illinois and Minnesota.

8. https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/i...h3AZzFsvKT2tr7 ABC News Cut the red tape: help Wisconsin and Ukraine Milwaukee Journal Sentinel (blog)-Apr 14, 2014 Wisconsin has vastly benefited from the American shale gas revolution. A key resource ... In 2010 there were just five sand mines in Wisconsin.

9. Knight Life: Statewide conservation hearings cover fishing, hunting ... Leader-Telegram-20 hours ago A resolution calling for a study of silica sand mining in Wisconsin, introduced by Thomas Peterson of rural Augusta, passed 75 to 15. The study ...