Thread: Grassroots Immigration Group: Amnesty Is Worse than No Wall

Grassroots Immigration Group: Amnesty Is Worse than No Wall

January 22, 2019

Neil Munro






President Donald Trump should not offer a combined “DACA-Dreamer” amnesty to win “one-tenth of a border fence,” says William Gheen, founder of the grassroots Americans for Legal Immigration PAC group.

“Every single amnesty bill we’ve seen for 15 years has been filled with all sorts of restrictions and enforcement promises designed to garner votes in Congress and give lawmakers things to cover their asses with angry constituents,” Gheen told Breitbart News. He continued:

Each time we have found language in the bill that allows all enforcement to be skipped or ignored or they will just pass it and ignore the enforcement restrictions like the ’86 Amnesty. It is completely offensive and wrong that the U.S. Senate is even considering anything like Dreamer or DACA Amnesty considering the way the nation voted in 2016 to try to go in a different direction.

The statement was made after Trump announced his support for a deal in which he would get $5.7 billion for border wall funding in exchange for endorsing three-year work permit amnesties for one million people in the DACA and Temporary Protected Status programs. The exchange is supported by business groups who are clamoring for more imported workers to help suppress wage raises before the 2020 election.

Gheen said Trump’s deputies are planning to offer more giveaways to Democrats and business-first Republicans in exchange for a “DACA-Dreamer amnesty.”

Trump “is only hearing from CEOs,” said Rosemary Jenks, policy director at the Numbers USA group, which favors reduced migration. Trump should not give up on his wage-raising “Hire American” policy, especially for white-collar professionals threated by the H-1B program, she said, adding:

The people he campaigned with, the [H-1B-] displaced workers, are just distraught. If he helps wages and job opportunities grow for Americans, he will turn out voters in 2020. If he helps put in place more policies that harm American workers and wages, he will not turn out voters.

In a press statement, ALIPAC said:

ALIPAC calls on Amnesty Trump to end his “Trump Wall Pretense” now that it is clear he’s using the issue to promote border destroying Amnesty for illegal immigrants.
…
While originally supportive of a massive new wall on the southern border, ALIPAC is dropping support for Trump’s wall efforts because he is only building fencing and he is only seeking a small fraction of funding needed for border structures in exchange for Amnesty for illegal immigrants which will render any borders and defenses moot.

From this point forward, ALIPAC will refer to the President as Amnesty Trump and to his deceptive bait and switch promises of a border wall as “Trump’s Wall Pretense” now that President Trump is using the wall issue to advance DACA and Immigration Reform Amnesty for illegals.
…
ALIPAC also feels that Trump’s chances of reelection in 2020 are now very low because Trump will never be able to rally and mobilize millions of American voters, like those at ALIPAC, who responded to his campaign promises about border security and illegal immigration.

Gheen’s ALIPAC does not have an office in Washington D.C., but it played major roles in defeating the 2006 and 2007 would-be amnesties, and the 2010 push to amnesty the large population of “Dreamer” young illegals. In 2014, the group also helped to kill off the 2013 “Gang of Eight” cheap labor amnesty by helping ensure the primary defeat of GOP Majority Leader Eric Cantor.

We need Trump supporters to understand that DACA & "immigration reform" are both Amnesty for illegal aliens. pic.twitter.com/tduCeSmGn7
— William Gheen (@ALIPAC) January 21, 2019

ALIPAC drops support for @realDonaldTrump Trump's Wall Pretense as an Amnesty Vehicle #StopDACA
https://t.co/qiiiCMvrf3pic.twitter.com/c6YGx1hBUL
— William Gheen (@ALIPAC) January 22, 2019

Other pro-American advocates are growing concerned about the pro-amnesty push among officials in Trump’s White House. Breitbart News reported:

Co-host of the “Red Pilled America” podcast Patrick Courrielche told Breitbart News that while amnesty would be a boon to DACA illegal aliens, it would hurt the very Americans who supported Trump.

“Trump promised us no amnesty,” Courrielche said. “Passing DACA amnesty knowing the devastating results of Reagan’s amnesty on American workers and families would be an unforgivable betrayal. I’d prefer no wall deal if it includes legalizing DACA.”

A DACA amnesty would put more U.S.-born children of illegal aliens — commonly known as “anchor babies” — on federal welfare, as Breitbart News reported, while American taxpayers would be left with a $26 billion bill.

Mickey Kaus is also urging Trump to preserve his wage-raising “Hire American” policy by trading non-immigration policies to win the wall:

Another potential avenue for shutdown-ending compromise: How about 'We stop screwing around with Obamacare' for Wall (instead of trading the wall for an amnesty that will encourage a surge across the border before the wall is built)?
Surely Obamacare is something Dems care about https://t.co/VgjO4no3eX
— Mickey Kaus (@kausmickey) January 22, 2019

Another thing Trump could maybe offer the Dems in exchange for the wall: Legislation ending debt-ceiling shutdowns.
Would be an organically relevant way to end this one.

He doesn't have to offer DACA. There are other things Dems want. https://t.co/xVyGKCvbhh
— Mickey Kaus (@kausmickey) January 18, 2019

Ann Coulter is the strongest advocate for a wall, and she argues that Trump should anti – offer to swap support some Democratic priorities, such as “a higher federal minimum wage, an infrastructure bill, a solar panel bill.”

There are a million things to trade for a wall: A higher federal minimum wage, an infrastructure bill, a solar panel bill. Trade a wall for AMNESTY, and there's no purpose to having a wall. https://t.co/7rv6UaVbDE
— Ann Coulter (@AnnCoulter) January 19, 2019

Gheen’s opposition to the pending amnesty-for-wall trade was ridiculed by Todd Schulte, the D.C. director of a pro-migration advocacy group funded by Silicon Valley investors:

Ooohhhh—super nutso @ALIPACditching the wall as a priority because deporting Dreamers is more important to them. https://t.co/VgSOaneiWn
— Todd Schulte (@TheToddSchulte) January 22, 2019

Schulte’s investors want more H-1B visa workers to cut their payroll costs, and they want more immigrant customers for their new companies. The group’s investors include Mark Zuckerberg, the multi-billionaire founder of Facebook.


The establishment’s economic policy of using legal and illegal migration to boost economic growth shifts enormous wealth from young people towards older people by flooding the market with cheap white-collar and blue-collar foreign labor.

That annual flood of roughly one million legal immigrants — as well as visa workers and illegal immigrants — spikes profits and Wall Street values by shrinking salaries for 150 million blue-collar and white-collar employees and especially wages for the four million young Americans who join the labor force each year.


The cheap labor policy widens wealth gaps, reduces high tech investment, increases state and local tax burdens, hurts kids’ schools and college education, pushes Americans away from high tech careers, and sidelines millions of marginalized Americans, including many who are now struggling with fentanyl addictions.


Immigration also steers investment and wealth away from towns in Heartland states because coastal investors can more easily hire and supervise the large immigrant populations who prefer to live in coastal cities. In turn, that coastal investment flow drives up coastal real estate prices and pushes poor U.S. Americans, including Latinos and blacks, out of prosperous cities such as Berkeley and Oakland.

Tech Billionaires urge fast-track green cards for 400,000 contract visa-workers – and many more later. Just guessing here, but maybe most Americans prefer fewer visa workers for biz & higher salaries for their families? https://t.co/yXhMswXOXK
— Neil Munro (@NeilMunroDC) December 8, 2018



https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2...-than-no-wall/

Amnesty Vote Thursday: New Article & Calls

News reports indicate a vote on Trump's Amnesty bill for 1 million illegal aliens, which is as large as the 1986 Amnesty under Reagan that caused us to have 20 million illegals today, will take place tomorrow (Thursday) in the US Senate!

That gives us just 24 hours!

ALIPAC has landed and a new blow against the bill, but it all depends on you now.

Take Action Now! We need you to ...


1. Keep flooding the GOP offices in the US Senate to fight against tomorrow's Amnesty bill using ALIPAC's messages, tactics, and targets found here...
https://www.alipac.us/f8/call-stop-d...-today-369282/


2. Please read, make a supportive comment, and then help circulate this article to sites like Drudge, and on social media where you can see ALIPAC and other Border Hawks fighting this Amnesty bill. The more people you can get to read this article with us leading the fight, the better our chances at stopping Amnesty tomorrow!

Grassroots Immigration Group: Amnesty Is Worse than No Wall

https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2019/01/22/grassroots-immigration-group-amnesty-is-worse-than-no-wall/

Reopen the government immediately with a wall, without a wall but no amnesty for anyone. If no wall, have the military build the wall like was planned before this stupid shutdown.

Reopen it with no DACA and TPS amnesty.

Let the military build the wall.

Start passing the bills to end birthright citizenship, cut off the freebies and enforce Public Charge.

Start investigating EVERY DACA application and deport the ones who committed crimes and lied.

ROUND UP THE DAPA PARENTS WHO ARE HERE ILLEGALLY AND DEPORT THEM TOO!

NO MORE EXTENSIONS...LET THE COURTS SHUT THIS DOWN AND ISSUE NOTICE OF DEPORTATION

THIS MOB IS COMING HERE BECAUSE THEIR ILLEGAL FAMILIES ARE HERE!

KEEP THE FAMILY TOGETHER...DEPORT THEM TOGETHER ON THE SAME MASSIVE BARGE BACK HOME!

Trump & Kushner Amnesty Inspires Draft Ann Coulter for MAGA President Campaign

For National Release | January 24, 2019


Share & debate this release by e-mail and on (FACEBOOK HERE) .. (TWITTER HERE) .. (GAB HERE) .. (ALIPAC HERE)

https://www.alipac.us/f8/trumps-amne...mpaign-369354/