Thread: Supreme Court limits president's recess appointment power

Supreme Court limits president's recess appointment power

Published June 26, 2014 FoxNews.com

March 5, 2014: The exterior of the U.S. Supreme Court is seen in Washington.Reuters


The Supreme Court delivered a blow Thursday to President Obama, ruling that he went too far in making recess appointments to the National Labor Relations Board.

In a unanimous decision, the high court sided with Senate Republicans and limited the president's power to fill high-level vacancies with temporary appointments. It was the first-ever Supreme Court test involving the long-standing practice of presidents naming appointees when the Senate is on break.

In this case, Obama had argued that the Senate was on an extended holiday break when he filled slots at the NLRB in 2012. He argued the brief sessions it held every three days were a sham that was intended to prevent him from filling the seats.

The justices rejected that argument, though, declaring the Senate was not actually in a formal recess when Obama acted during that three-day window.
Justice Stephen Breyer said in his majority opinion that a congressional break has to last at least 10 days to be considered a recess under the Constitution.

"Three days is too short a time to bring a recess within the scope of the Clause. Thus we conclude that the President lacked the power to make the recess appointments here at issue," Breyer wrote.

At the same time, the court upheld the general authority of the president to make recess appointments.

Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell, among those who criticized the president for unilaterally filling the NLRB slots, applauded the high court decision on Thursday.

"The president made an unprecedented power grab by placing political allies at a powerful federal agency while the Senate was meeting regularly and without even bothering to wait for its advice and consent," he said in a statement. "A unanimous Supreme Court has rejected this brazen power-grab."

On a separate track, House Speaker John Boehner said a day earlier he plans to proceed with a lawsuit against the president over his alleged abuse of executive power.

The issue of recess appointments receded in importance after the Senate's Democratic majority changed the rules to make it harder for Republicans to block confirmation of most Obama appointees.

But the ruling's impact may be keenly felt by the White House next year if Republicans capture control of the Senate in the November election. The potential importance of the ruling lies in the Senate's ability to block the confirmation of judges and the leaders of independent agencies like the NLRB. A federal law gives the president the power to appoint acting heads of Cabinet-level departments to keep the government running.

Still, the outcome could have been worse for the administration. The justices, by a 5-4 vote, rejected a sweeping lower court ruling against the administration that would have made it virtually impossible for any future president to make recess appointments.

The lower court held that the only recess recognized by the Constitution is the once-a-year break between sessions of Congress. It also said that only vacancies that arise in that recess could be filled. So the high court has left open the possibility that a president, with a compliant Congress, could make recess appointments in the future.

The case decided Thursday arose out of a dispute between the NLRB and a Pepsi-Cola distributor, Noel Canning. The NLRB had ruled against him in a labor dispute, but Canning argued that three of the five board members were improperly appointed.

A recess appointment can last no more than two years. Recess appointees who subsequently won Senate confirmation include Chief Justice Earl Warren and Justice William Brennan, Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan, two current NLRB members and Consumer Financial Protection Bureau director Richard Cordray. Former UN Ambassador John Bolton is among recess appointees who left office because they could not win a Senate vote.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.

http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2014...intment-power/

Realtime Coverage

Supreme Court Curbs President's Power to Make Recess Appointments New York Times - ‎55 minutes ago‎ WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Thursday said President Obama had violated the Constitution when he bypassed the Senate to appoint officials to the National Labor Relations Board during a brief break in the Senate's work. But the larger message ... Bloomberg WJXT Jacksonville NBCNews.com 89.3 KPCC Port Huron Times Herald Business Insider Wall Street Journal Fox News (blog) Daily Beast The Atlantic Mother Jones POLITICO Magazine FOX News Radio WRGT TV Fox 45 Raw Story Breitbart News The Guardian KTLA Constitution Daily (blog) Reason (blog) Kline, Bachmann applaud Supreme Court ruling on presidential appointments Minneapolis Star Tribune - ‎8 minutes ago‎ High Court Rebukes Obama, Rejects Recess Appts. Christian Broadcasting Network - ‎9 minutes ago‎ Supreme Court limits, but also preserves, recess appointment powers Constitution Daily (blog) - ‎10 minutes ago‎ AG Schmidt: Supreme Court unanimously backs states' role in presidential ... Kansas First News - ‎12 minutes ago‎ SUPCO Ruling on Executive Power Example of Problems with Antiquated System Newswise (press release) - ‎14 minutes ago‎ In Depth High court rules against Obama on recess appointments USA TODAY - ‎1 hour ago‎ WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court dealt a blow to the powers of the presidency Thursday, ruling decisively that President Obama violated the Constitution by going around the Senate to name key labor and financial watchdogs. Resolving a longstanding ... High court rebukes Obama on recess appointments Kansas City Star - ‎25 minutes ago‎ The Supreme Court on Thursday limited the president's power to fill high-level vacancies with temporary appointments, ruling in favor of Senate Republicans in their partisan clash with President Barack Obama. The high court's first case involving the ... US top court curbs presidential power on appointments Chicago Tribune - ‎11 minutes ago‎ WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday ruled against President Barack Obama by cutting back the power of the White House to temporarily fill senior government posts when facing partisan opposition in Congress, although it stopped ... Your preferred source Supreme Court rules against Obama on recess appointments Los Angeles Times - ‎33 minutes ago‎ President Obama used his recess appointment power to name Richard Cordray, right, to head the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. He later won Senate confirmation. President Obama used his recess appointment power to name Richard Cordray, right ... Obama Recess Appointments Illegal, Supreme Court Finds U.S. News & World Report - ‎19 minutes ago‎ Justices say presidents can only make recess appointments when the Senate says it's in recess. The Associated Press. President Barack Obama's power to make recess appointments was limited Thursday by the U.S. Supreme Court. By Steven Nelson June ... Supreme Court Narrows President's Recess-Appointment Powers Wall Street Journal - ‎2 hours ago‎ WASHINGTON—The Supreme Court ruled Thursday that President Barack Obama exceeded his authority in appointing three National Labor Relations Board members during a brief Senate break in 2012, holding presidents may only exercise their ... SUPCO Ruling on Executive Power Example of Problems with Antiquated System Newswise (press release) - ‎14 minutes ago‎ David J. Andersen, an assistant professor of political science at Iowa State University, says the Supreme Court ruling on President Obama's recess appointments is an example of modern government running into problems caused by a 200-year-old ... Retailers Hail Supreme Court Decision on NLRB Appointments The Herald | HeraldOnline.com (press release) - ‎1 hour ago‎ WASHINGTON — The National Retail Federation released the following statement from Senior Vice President for Government Relations David French on the U.S. Supreme Court decision in National Labor Relations Board v. Noel Canning, which questioned ... Opinion How will Unconstitutional Obama Recess Appointments Affect Minnesota Labor ... Minneapolis Star Tribune - ‎1 hour ago‎ In a unanimous decision this morning, the U.S. Supreme Court just overturned recess appointments made by President Obama in 2012 to the Labor Relations Board. The big question now: Will the cases decided by the NLRB during the period in question ... All nine justices reject recess appointments in Noel Canning case Washington Post - ‎2 hours ago‎ The Supreme Court has issued yet another opinion unanimous in the judgment: Noel Canning v. NLRB. All nine justices conclude that President Obama's recess appointments to the National Labor Relations Board were invalid. Justice Stephen Breyer ... Obama Loses at the Supreme Court Daily Beast - ‎4 hours ago‎ The Supreme Court ruled unanimously on Thursday that President Obama's move to fill three seats on the National Labor Relations Board in 2012 using recess appointments exceeded his power. The Court ruled that the Senate was not truly in recess when ... See all 336 articles »

How Many Recess Appointments Have Other Presidents Made

www.dailykos.com/.../-How-Many-Recess-Appointments-Have...
Daily Kos
5 hours ago - So far, Obama has made recess appointments 32 times, according to a Feb. ... Let me reemphasize this: Ronald Reagan 232, George W. Bush 171, Bill Clinton 139, George H. W.Bush 78 ...