Thread: A Game With No Winner

A Game With No Winner
By New York Times News Service

Published on 2/28/2007


It's almost enough to make us nostalgic for streaking and sitting on flagpoles. College students from Michigan to Florida have found a new way to get attention, offend others and make a right-wing statement all at once. It's a game with a name that says it all: “Catch the Illegal Immigrant.”

The game is a variation on hide and seek: one player poses as the immigrant, and everyone else tries to find that person. There's a prize, usually $200 or less, which is not much, but enough to celebrate the cheap exploitation of a fellow human.

“Catch the Immigrant” is the brainchild of an intern with the College Republican National Committee, who lost her post after coming up with this and other campus recruitment gimmicks. Another game, called “Fun With Guns,” invited young Republicans to fire BB guns or paint balls at cardboard cutouts of Democratic leaders. Republican Party leaders have tried to distance themselves from the games, but seem to have done little to stop them.

The right-wing organizers of the immigrant games — particularly Young Americans for Freedom and Young Republicans — have declared piously that they're just trying to spark debate. At that, they have succeeded. Protesters defending immigration and human dignity have outnumbered the game's players at the University of Michigan, Michigan State, Pennsylvania State and other campuses, including, most recently, at New York University.

The reaction from schools has been mostly tepid. Administrators are in a tough spot, trying to balance free speech with offensive behavior. More speech is the answer, including voices of authority pointing out the nastiness of this game as well as the inherent cruelty of hunting people for sport.

“Catch the Immigrant” also reflects a larger misunderstanding of the immigration issue. The more than 11 million illegal immigrants cannot be caught. Even if they could be, rounding them up and deporting them would be disastrous, economically and socially. Educators should teach the game players about the real world.

(Educators should teach game players that yes you can deport 11 million people. Instead of trying to brain wash them into submission with the thought that it's impossible.

We got along without them, we can do it again. Maybe they should teach them that one shouldn't ignore what's going on at our borders as our government has since 1986.

These so called educators should teach these students that our government is ignoring the problem instead of enforcing the present laws that deal with this issue..

Maybe these so called educators should discuss why our government does not uphold their sworn in oath to uphold the law of the constitution. Teach that instead of teaching submission!)


http://www.theday.com/re.aspx?re=ebaf4e ... 2b5291e6c5

If that's the best these shallow college kids can come up with on the prospect of losing their nation, I pity their future families.