We keep spinning our wheels because of this kind of nonsense. This law would be unconstitutional. It violates the 14th amendment. To make a law constitutional it would have to be phrased something like the following: No person born inside or outside the U S who has one parent who is in the U S illegally at the time of birth, or one parent who has ever been inside the U S illegally prior to birth is not subject to the jurdiction thereof of the United States for the purpose of citizenship.