Thread: FAIR Report Released: Costs of Illegal Immigration to Iowans

Costs of Illegal Immigration to Iowans


Iowa has a fast growing illegal alien population of at least 55,000 persons, and the fiscal burden on Iowans resulting from services provided to that population are similarly growing rapidly. Comparing this number with the federal government estimate of 24,000 illegal immigrants in 2000 suggests that the illegal resident alien population has grown by roughly 31,000 persons — an increase of 130 percent — over the past seven years. A comparison of the entire foreign-born population residing in Iowa in the 2000 Census — including legal and illegal immigrants and some long-term nonimmigrants, such as foreign students — with the estimated size of that foreign-born population in 2006 also shows an increase of about 31,000 people. This suggests that virtually all of the increase in the foreign-born population in Iowa since 2000 has been by illegal residents.

This rapid rise in the illegal alien population in Iowa since 2000 has coincided with the implementation of a program termed the New Iowans Project. The New Iowans centers are still operating in the state.

FAIR estimates that the annual fiscal burden on Iowa taxpayers today from illegal immigration is at least $241 million. That equates to an annual cost of about $172 per native-born headed Iowa household after accounting for taxes collected from illegal workers.

This study takes into account the findings of a report prepared by Iowa’s Legislative Services Agency (LSA) in February 2007 and by the Iowa Policy Project (IPP) in response to the LSA report. Our estimates, based on a different methodology, reveal a greater fiscal burden than reported in either of those studies. Even without accounting for all areas in which costs associated with illegal immigration are being incurred by Iowa taxpayers, the program areas analyzed in this study indicate that the burden is substantial. The nearly one-quarter billion dollar costs incurred by Iowa taxpayers annually result from outlays in the following areas:

Education. Based on an estimate of 8,645 school-age illegal aliens and 12,100 U.S.-born children of illegal aliens in Iowa and estimated per pupil costs of $8,450 per year for public K-12 schooling, Iowans spend about $175.3 million annually on education for the children of illegal immigrants. An additional estimated $13 million is being spent annually on programs for limited English students who are likely children of illegal aliens. More than four percent of the K-12 public school students in Iowa are children of illegal aliens, and this share has been increasing as the illegal resident population increases and the overall public school enrollment has decreased slightly

Health care. State-funded uncompensated medical outlays for health care provided to Iowa’s illegal alien population amount to an estimated $48.3 million a year. This estimate does not include higher medical bills and insurance costs that Iowans who have medical insurance pay to cover the costs of those without insurance.

Incarceration. The uncompensated cost of incarcerating deportable illegal aliens in Iowa’s state and local prisons amounts to nearly $4.9 million a year. This estimate excludes compensation from the federal government, short-term detention costs, related law enforcement and judicial expenditures, as well as the monetary costs of the crimes that led to incarceration.

If this report does not piss off Iowa residents nothing will. It does me and i'm not a resident of Iowa!

Sadly, though, this report probably UNDERreports the true fiscal impact of IAs on state and local budgets. Why?

1. The cost associated with educating IAs is probably low-ball in that it accounts for the per year cost of placing the student in school for a year - it assumes... the school is already built, staffed and waiting. However, as many local tax districts/education districts can tell you, with any large spike in local population, there is an 'up-front' investment cost in just getting the infrastructure funded and built. The per year cost, really does not account for the hit forced on the local communities up-front.

2. Incarceration - well, so these IAs suddenly reported themselves to the authorities (eg. assumes no investigations took place), declined a jury trial and went straight to prison??? I don't think so. The costs to investigate, prosecute are hardly inconsequential.

3. Etc., etc.

At least FAIR chose to crunch some numbers to come up with an estimate, but the true numbers are probably worse than reported here.

The silence from the media is deafening on this story. Hopefully it will make page 29 in major newspapers just below the section where they list fictitious business announcements.

Originally Posted by PhredE

Sadly, though, this report probably UNDERreports the true fiscal impact of IAs on state and local budgets. Why?

1. The cost associated with educating IAs is probably low-ball in that it accounts for the per year cost of placing the student in school for a year - it assumes... the school is already built, staffed and waiting. However, as many local tax districts/education districts can tell you, with any large spike in local population, there is an 'up-front' investment cost in just getting the infrastructure funded and built. The per year cost, really does not account for the hit forced on the local communities up-front.

2. Incarceration - well, so these IAs suddenly reported themselves to the authorities (eg. assumes no investigations took place), declined a jury trial and went straight to prison??? I don't think so. The costs to investigate, prosecute are hardly inconsequential.

3. Etc., etc.


At least FAIR chose to crunch some numbers to come up with an estimate, but the true numbers are probably worse than reported here.

NO doubt about that "Phred"

In Texas, it cost would cost the state about 25 million just to educate those 8,000 kids a year.

If my math is right, I beleive it cost the state about 1 million per 650. Not to mention the free lunch programs, medical treatment, shots.... That's all extra.

Not to mention, those taxed workers use their anchor babies to get earned income tax refunds. Illegal aliens don't pay taxes people!!!!!!! They are even bitter about paying sales taxes and sin tax on liquor.

Dixie

Originally Posted by PhredE

Sadly, though, this report probably UNDERreports the true fiscal impact of IAs on state and local budgets. Why?

1. The cost associated with educating IAs is probably low-ball in that it accounts for the per year cost of placing the student in school for a year - it assumes... the school is already built, staffed and waiting. However, as many local tax districts/education districts can tell you, with any large spike in local population, there is an 'up-front' investment cost in just getting the infrastructure funded and built. The per year cost, really does not account for the hit forced on the local communities up-front.

2. Incarceration - well, so these IAs suddenly reported themselves to the authorities (eg. assumes no investigations took place), declined a jury trial and went straight to prison??? I don't think so. The costs to investigate, prosecute are hardly inconsequential.

3. Etc., etc.

At least FAIR chose to crunch some numbers to come up with an estimate, but the true numbers are probably worse than reported here.

Good points, Phred. These are all unrecognized costs!!!