Thread: Singapore might cane American who overstayed visa

Singapore might cane American who overstayed visa

By the CNN Wire StaffOctober 22, 2010 1:49 a.m. EDT
Caning is widely used as punishment in Singapore.

(CNN) -- An American businessman could face three strokes with a cane for overstaying his visa in Singapore, his legal defense team said Friday.

Kamari Charlton, 37, also could face a six-month jail sentence if convicted.

Charlton was about to leave Singapore with his pregnant wife when he was arrested at the airport on September 1, said Arun Maaran of Charlton's defense team. He's been in jail since.

His wife is thought to have returned to the Bahamas, where they live, Maaran said. Contact has been sporadic, because she is thought to have been hospitalized with complications to her pregnancy.

Consular officers from the U.S. Embassy have visited Charlton's six times, said spokeswoman Rachel Ehrendreich.

Caning is widely used as punishment in Singapore, but Charlton's case is unique, his defense team argues. His wife was in the country on a six-month medical visa, while he was on a three-month tourist visa. Unlike most offenders who overstay, Maaran said, Charlton was not in Singapore to take advantage of its strong economy by working illegally. He overstayed by 169 days, according to court documents.

The former Florida State University college football player now successfully runs a construction company, his legal team says.

Charlton's case was to be heard late Friday afternoon, to decide whether he has been discriminated against. If he prevails, his case could end up in high court and be resolved within a week or two. But many legal scenarios could play out and the case could drag on, though, Maaran said.

The discrimination argument is based on another case involving overstaying a visa. A cousin of Charlton's wife also overstayed, but was allowed to leave Singapore after paying a fine, Maaran said.

If convicted, Charlton would be caned unless he could provided a medical reason otherwise.

The case is reminiscent of the 1994 case of American teenager Michael Faye, who was sentenced to caning for vandalism in Singapore. After U.S. officials requested leniency, the Singapore government reduced the number of lashes he was given.

The U.S. Embassy in Singapore is closely monitoring Charlton's case, Ehrendreich said.

"We remind U.S. citizens that foreigners in any country are subject to the laws of that country," she said. "We respect Singapore's right to try and sentence individuals within due process of law."

http://www.cnn.com/2010/WORLD/asiapcf/1 ... gletoolbar

if he over stayed his visa and he knew he was overstaying his visa then they have every right to cane his ass ....

i wish we did it like there ..

Caning is widely used as punishment in Singapore, but Charlton's case is unique, his defense team argues. His wife was in the country on a six-month medical visa, while he was on a three-month tourist visa. Unlike most offenders who overstay, Maaran said, Charlton was not in Singapore to take advantage of its strong economy by working illegally. He overstayed by 169 days, according to court documents.

Ok...I never claimed to be a math wizard, but something does not seem right here. He had 90 days of free time on his tourist visa, but overstayed according to court documents 169 days. That's 259 days total that he was in Singapore! His wife was only granted 180 days on her medical visa.

So it would seem we have a total of 90 days that cannot be explained based upon information provided. What was he doing? It would make sense if he overstayed his visa by 90 days because he was by his wife's side dealing with her presumed "medical issues."

In any event, man-up and take your punishment like a man and next time, OBEY the law of the country you're in! Unlike the United States, some countries actually take overstaying a visa and protecting their borders quite seriously!

In any event, I have spent way too much time analyzing this...LOL!