Thread: Analysis: McCain's uphill battle on illegal immigration

Polls show Sen. John McCain with about a third of the Hispanic vote nationwide.


http://www.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/06/21/ ... hispanics/

WASHINGTON (CNN) -- In recent days, Sen. Barack Obama has backed off his harshest criticisms of the North American Free Trade Agreement, and he's changed his stance on campaign financing, electing to decline the federal funds for the general election -- prompting charges of flip-flopping.


Obama's campaign says Sen. John McCain has contradictions of his own, namely on illegal immigration.

On Wednesday night, McCain held a private meeting with more than 150 Chicago, Illinois-area Hispanic leaders.

According to The Associated Press, several people who were at the meeting said McCain assured them that he would push for comprehensive immigration reform if he's elected president.

In 2007, McCain's sponsorship of comprehensive immigration reform angered conservatives and very nearly derailed his presidential campaign.

At a Republican debate at the Reagan Library in January, McCain was asked whether he would still vote for his original measure.

"No, I would not ... because we know what the situation is today ... that people want the borders secured first," he said.


"The original proposal, I opposed. Sen. McCain's new proposal, I support, which is to ensure you have border security before you have any other type of reform," L.A. County Supervisor Mike Antonovich said.

After the Chicago meeting, the Obama campaign's communications director, Robert Gibbs, charged that McCain was trying to have it both ways.

"It's hard for me to understand how you can sit in front of 150 Hispanic leaders in Chicago and leave them with the impression that you support comprehensive immigration reform and have that not directly contradict the fact that sitting in the Reagan Library in the midst of a Republican primary. How you can say that you didn't intend to vote for your own bill," Gibbs said.

McCain is now getting just over a third of the Hispanic vote nationwide, according to CNN/Opinion Research Corp. Polls from April and June. Obama garnered 61 percent to McCain's 34 percent.

In 2004, President Bush got about 40 percent.

McCain must try to keep conservatives happy while making sure his Hispanic support doesn't collapse.

How's he going to do it? His campaign says he will be addressing several major Hispanic groups in the next month.

CNN asked the McCain campaign for a response to Gibbs' comments. A spokesman said, "Despite the wildly misinformed opinions of Barack Obama's spokesman, John McCain fundamentally believes that we need to secure our border, and then move forward to address the need for immigration reform in a respectful and compassionate manner that recognizes that we are all God's children. That's his position yesterday, today and every other day -- before all the groups he meets with.''

When people mention that someone else is being deported to Mexico to some people it conjures up a particular idea. A removal to Mexico means loss of hope but a better informed person would realize that Mexico is a land of potential. If someone says I am leaving for Canada there is more realization that the quality of life is not far behind that of the United States. Mexico is a place that will have the same impression as Canada but for it to happen it calls for Mexicans
to put effort into improvement of their country currently put into illegal immigration.

CNN asked the McCain campaign for a response to Gibbs' comments. A spokesman said, "Despite the wildly misinformed opinions of Barack Obama's spokesman, John McCain fundamentally believes that we need to secure our border, and then move forward to address the need for immigration reform in a respectful and compassionate manner that recognizes that we are all God's children. That's his position yesterday, today and every other day -- before all the groups he meets with.''

I really get angered when McLame starts up with his "compassion and God's children" pablum. Juan McInsane...what does "Gods children" have to do with illegal immigration??? Are you saying they are a special kind of Gods children deserving of some special consideration and benefits at the expense of all the other of Gods children (American citizens and legal immigrants)? Yeah, Juan...they are a special class of Gods children...lawbreakers, invaders, liars and cheats.

Obama campaign's communications director, Robert Gibbs, charged that McCain was trying to have it both ways.

"It's hard for me to understand how you can sit in front of 150 Hispanic leaders in Chicago and leave them with the impression that you support comprehensive immigration reform and have that not directly contradict the fact that sitting in the Reagan Library in the midst of a Republican primary. How you can say that you didn't intend to vote for your own bill," Gibbs said.

For once I agree with something from the Obama campaign.

Based on John McCain's comments during the Reagan Library debate and based on the fact that right before the California primary (which forced Romney to quit shortly thereafter) he ran tough sounding ads about border security, one could get the distinct impression that he doesn't support amnesty -- which most of us know is bunk as he always has, and still does, support mass amnesty.

Their both Liars, plain and simple they say what they have to in front of what that paticular group expects to hear from them.

No telling what either one will do as president because they can not be trusted.