Thread: Baltimore police investigation doesn't support some of prosecution's charges

Sources: Baltimore police investigation doesn't support some of prosecution's charges

By Evan Perez, Shimon Prokupecz and Wesley Bruer, CNN
Updated 11:41 AM ET, Thu May 7, 2015

Baltimore (CNN)The Baltimore police investigation into the death of Freddie Gray doesn't support some of the charges, including the most serious, filed by the Baltimore City State's Attorney, potentially allowing lawyers representing the police officers the opportunity to undercut the prosecution, according to officials briefed on the separate probes conducted by the State's Attorney and police.

Already, defense attorneys are filing motions seeking to exploit differences between the separate state attorney and police investigations.

Lawyers for two officers have challenged a key finding of State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby's case: that a knife found on Freddie Gray was legal in Maryland and therefore the officers didn't have a right to arrest Gray. The police investigation found that the knife is illegal under Baltimore city code.



Baltimore officer: Freddie Gray's knife was illegal 02:11

PLAY VIDEO

RELATED: Was Freddie Gray's knife legal?

Officials familiar with the probes also say the homicide investigation run by police investigators at most contemplated a manslaughter charge, not second degree murder as Mosby charged one of the officers, Caesar Goodson. To win conviction for murder, prosecutors must prove intent to kill. Manslaughter relates to unintentional killings.

In addition, homicide investigators who were briefed by the medical examiner's office believed the examiner's autopsy report would likely find the cause of death to fall short of homicide, according to one official familiar with the case.

Instead, Mosby said that the medical examiner concluded that Gray's death was a homicide and that Gray's fatal injury to the head occurred in a police transport van that was taking him to the police precinct.

RELATED: Community donates to looted Baltimore store

According to an official with Maryland's office of the chief medical examiner, where Gray's autopsy was performed, information was shared with police investigators throughout the process, a common practice. But the official said there is only one conclusion on manner of death and that was contained in the final autopsy report delivered to Mosby on the same day she announced her decision to bring charges.

Another issue could arise from the team Mosby relied on to lead her case: one of her top investigators, Avon Mackel, is a former high-ranking Baltimore police officer who was stripped of his command post in 2009 for failing to follow through on a robbery investigation that two of his officers mishandled and did not report. A Baltimore Sun report said police in the district were accused of classifying serious crimes as lesser in order to log lower crime rates.



Mayor asks DOJ to investigate Baltimore police 01:11

PLAY VIDEO

RELATED: Baltimore's top cop admits 'we are part of the problem'

In October 2009, four months after his demotion, Baltimore County police sent a SWAT team to Mackel's home, responding a drunken incident in which he was seen holding a gun, according to a police report of the incident obtained by CNN.

Officers said an intoxicated Mackel refused to cooperate and was visibly upset, according to the report provided in response to a public records request. An officer then "observed the barrel of Mackel's handgun hanging over the edge of the molding at the top of the steps and saw Mackel pull the gun out of sight," the report said.

Police used a Taser on Mackel while he was on the phone with his father "crying and yelling," before he barricaded himself in his bedroom. The report doesn't say how the incident ended, but police said there was no arrest. A spokesman for the Baltimore County Police Department said "the [SWAT] tactical unit did assist with this incident, which ended peacefully."

Mackel didn't respond to calls and emails seeking comment. No one answered at his home.

Defense attorneys working on the case are already digging for ways to attack weaknesses in Mosby's case, according to defenders of the officers. Mackel's past, and whether he holds it against the police department, could present opportunities for the defense.

That has lead to concerns among some city officials that if Mosby's case fails to hold up, community reaction could explode again.

"If this case falls apart, then does Baltimore burn?" one official said.
Mosby took pains to distance herself from the police with her separate probe, including using her own investigators and not relying on the 40-plus member police task force set up to look in the death of Freddie Gray.



Cleaning up after Baltimore riots 13 photos

EXPAND GALLERY

But that separation could cut both ways.

The police findings -- including those that contradict some of Mosby's investigation -- will now be part of the evidence provided to defense attorneys.

The Baltimore police department has declined to comment on the investigation since it is now in Mosby's hands.

A spokeswoman provided a statement on behalf of Mosby defending the charges.

"While the evidence we have obtained through our independent investigation does substantiate the elements of the charges filed, I refuse to litigate this case through the media," she said in the statement. "The evidence we have collected cannot ethically be disclosed, relayed or released to the public before trial. As I've previously indicated, I strongly condemn anyone in law enforcement with access to trial evidence, who has or continues to leak information prior to the resolution of this case. These unethical disclosures are only damaging our ability to conduct a fair and impartial process for all parties involved."

Mosby has good reason to separate her probe from the police.

There is widespread community distrust of the police. And many critics say letting police departments investigate themselves is partly why alleged excessive use of force incidents by officers rarely draw serious punishment.

Police Commissioner Anthony Batts told CNN in an exclusive interview on Tuesday that Mosby called him about 10 minutes before she told the world about the charges.

However, Batts had an inkling that Mosby was preparing for a surprise move, according to people familiar with the matter, which is why he turned over his department's findings a day ahead of the deadline he had set.

Complete coverage on Baltimore

http://www.cnn.com/2015/05/06/politi...y-prosecution/

http://www.alipac.us/f19/breaking-ne...micide-319161/

http://www.alipac.us/f19/baltimore-c...-order-319321/

Fri May 1, 2015 3:38pm EDT

Detroit prosecutor resigns after saying Baltimore rioters should be shot

DETROIT | BY SERENA MARIA DANIELS

A Detroit prosecutor who said on Facebook that people involved in Baltimore rioting should be shot has resigned, after her comments ignited fierce criticism, the prosecutor's office said on Friday.

Wayne County Assistant Prosecutor Teana Walsh had posted comments about this week's unrest in Baltimore, which was sparked by the death of Freddie Gray after he was fatally injured in police custody, according to a screenshot of her page posted on MyFox Detroit.com.

She described "large swarms of people throwing bricks etc at police who are fleeing from their assaults" and then suggested using guns.

"Simple. Shoot em. Period. End of discussion," Walsh posted.

The comment, which was criticized by local defense attorneys, has since been taken down from Facebook and Walsh's page is not accessible.

The death of 25-year-old Gray, who was black, has become the latest flashpoint in a national debate over the treatment of minority groups by U.S. law enforcement.

The populations of both Baltimore and Detroit are predominantly black. Nearly two-thirds of Baltimore's population and 83 percent of Detroit's is black. Both communities also experienced brutal race riots in the 1960s.

Walsh called Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy on Friday afternoon to say she was voluntarily resigning, and Worthy accepted, said assistant prosecutor Maria Miller in a statement on Friday.

“Walsh has been known for her great work ethic and her compassion for victims of crime and their families," Miller said.

"Her post was up on-line briefly and she immediately took it down. The post was completely out of character for her and certainly does not reflect the person that we know.”

On Friday, a Baltimore police officer was charged with murder and five others face lesser charges in Gray's death. The 25-year-old suffered a fatal neck injury while riding inside a police van, Baltimore's chief prosecutor said.

http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/...0NM4CK20150501

CNN BREAKING NEWS
​
Attorneys for the Baltimore police officers charged in the death of Freddie Gray have filed a motion for the recusal or dismissal of State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby's office from prosecuting the case.

Freddie Gray case: Defense attorneys call for prosecutor to be dismissed

By Steve Almasy, CNN
Updated 5:54 PM ET, Fri May 8, 2015

(CNN)Attorneys for the six Baltimore police officers charged in the death of Freddie Gray want the case dismissed or State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby's office to be taken off the case.

A lengthy motion filed in Baltimore City District Court cites a variety of concerns, including conflicts of interest and questions about the office's independent investigation.

It spells out five conflicts of interest as reasons for the requests. The attorneys say in their court filing that:

-- Mosby and her husband, City Council member Nick Mosby, stand to gain financially and politically;
-- She has personal relationships with potential witnesses;
-- Her office took a role investigating the case;
-- There is a pending civil lawsuit against her office;
-- An attorney for Gray's family is a close friend, supporter and a lawyer for Marilyn Mosby;

Gray was arrested April 12 for possessing an illegal knife and suffered a fatal spinal injury while being transported in a police van to a booking center, Mosby said.

http://www.cnn.com/2015/05/08/us/fre...ion/index.html

Charged cops: Remove her

BREAKING NEWS

​
Baltimore officers ask for new prosecutor

Motion cites variety of concerns about Marilyn Mosby, including alleged conflicts of interest. FULL STORY