Thread: Proposal by Vladimir Putin that the US allow Russia to question Michael McFaul met by

Proposal by Vladimir Putin that the US allow Russia to question Michael McFaul met by outrage in Washington

Guardian staff and agencies
Wed 18 Jul 2018 20.29 EDT

The White House has declined to rule out accepting a Russian proposal to question on US soil American people – including the former ambassador to Moscow Michael McFaul – sought by the Kremlin for “illegal activities”.

The proposal arose at Monday’s summit between the US president Donald Trump and the Russian president Vladimir Putin, and any decision by Washington to assist with an adversary’s prosecution of former government employees overseas would be a stunning shift in US policy, especially as it could violate the international legal principle of diplomatic immunity.

“The president is going to meet with his team and we’ll let you know when we have an announcement on that,” White House spokeswoman Sarah Sanders told a news briefing. Sanders added that Trump “said it was an interesting idea ... He wants to work with his team and determine if there is any validity that would be helpful to the process”.

Sanders’s comments prompted outrage in the US, including from McFaul, a vocal Putin critic.

“When Trump says Russia is no longer targeting America, that’s not how this American feels,” McFaul wrote on Twitter.

“Putin is most certainly targeting and intimidating me. And I’m an American.”

It comes after Putin suggested at the Helsinki summit that he would let US investigators be present for questioning of 12 Russian intelligence officers charged last Friday on allegations they carried out cyber attacks to interfere in the 2016 US election if Russians could do the same in America for people connected to money manager Bill Browder, a one-time investor in Russia. Browder has said he helped expose corruption in Russia.

Putin accused Browder of making campaign contributions to Trump’s election rival Hillary Clinton with money he earned in Russia on which he did not pay taxes. Putin said US intelligence officers helped Browder.

On Wednesday, the Russian prosecutor general’s office listed Americans it wants to question for “illegal activities”, including McFaul, who was US ambassador to Russia during the Obama administration and is now at Stanford University in California.

US State Department spokeswoman Heather Nauert called the Russian allegations “absolutely absurd”.

“The prosecutor general in Russia is well aware that the United States has rejected Russian allegations in this regard,” Nauert told a briefing.

McFaul told Reuters he has contacted Stanford lawyers. He denied Russia’s accusations and expressed deep concern that the White House failed to defend him.

“It’s crazy and should be called crazy and outrageous, not just by me, but by the US government,” McFaul said.

McFaul said the White House, by considering the request, was “assigning moral equivalence between a legitimate indictment of Russian intelligence officers ... to a cockamamie fantasy (from Moscow) with no basis in reality”.

The suggestion that the US would hand over a former ambassador to Russia caused deep disquiet in Washington.

Senior Democrat Adam Schiff said McFaul’s freedom was “not up for negotiation”.

Samantha Power, the former US ambassador to the UN, said Trump’s refusal to stand up to Putin was “a travesty”, while Democrat congressman Ted Lieu said it was “batshit crazy”.

Browder said on Fox Business Network that it was “just shocking” for Trump’s spokeswoman to say they were considering letting Russia question US officials.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/...michael-mcfaul

I posted several articles a year or so ago about this guy Bill Browder. He is not a US citizen and hasn't been since 1998. So he is no longer an American, no longer a US citizen, he's a British citizen, and renounced his US citizenship to avoid US income taxes. He's not even a dual-citizen. He's British by choice. So any questioning concerning him by Russian prosecutors would have to be taken up with the UK, because Browder is outside US jurisdiction.

Putin accused Browder of making campaign contributions to Trump’s election rival Hillary Clinton with money he earned in Russia on which he did not pay taxes. Putin said US intelligence officers helped Browder.

If true, isn't that a campaign finance violation? I was under the impression that foreign persons were not allowed to contribute to US election campaigns.

After the death in prison in 2009 of Sergei Magnitsky, a Russian lawyer and auditor who had represented his company and conducted an investigation into massive tax fraud related to it, Browder lobbied for Congress to pass the Magnitsky Act, a law to punish Russian human rights violators, which was signed into law in 2012 by President Barack Obama.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Browder

Why would our Congress pass a bill to appease a British citizen who renounced his US citizenship to avoid income taxes and was charged with tax evasion in Russia? What interest of the United States does this serve? Why would we create a serious dispute between the United States and Russia over it?! Makes no sense at all. This needs to be investigated. If our "intelligence officers" helped Browder cheat Russia on income taxes, we need to know why and if such a thing is even legal.