Thread: The Republicans’ Hispanic Delusion

City Journal
The Republicans’ Hispanic Delusion
Amnesty is not just wrong in principle, it’s bad politics.
Heather Mac Donald
6 June 2007

George Bush’s political strategists have long promoted amnesty for illegal aliens as a device for increasing the Republican vote among Hispanics. They also warn that denying rights to illegal aliens will hurt the GOP. A Hispanic backlash in California after Proposition 187 (the 1994 voter initiative that denied illegal aliens many publicly funded services) turned the state from red to blue, they claim; a similar rout awaits the party if it does not embrace liberal immigration policies.

There is scant evidence for either of these ideas. The 1986 amnesty signed by President Reagan did not trigger a Latino surge into the Republican Party. And California’s Hispanics leaned as strongly Democratic before Prop. 187 as after it. Hispanic voting patterns in California have held steady since 1988—they vote approximately two-to-one for Democratic presidential candidates. California’s shift from red to blue would have happened with or without Prop. 187, as defense-industry whites left the state, replaced by liberal high-tech professionals, and as the Hispanic portion of the electorate tripled from 7 percent to 21 percent.

“But Hispanics are Republicans waiting to emerge,â€

Not only that, the pandering to illegals by Republicans drives good Hispanics away. Don't you love what is said between the lines by neocon strategists on this topic - it is that Hispanics are the most racist voters in the world. Let some illegals in and they will be so happy!