Thread: SCHOLARS DEBUNK CLAIMS OF HIGH-TECH WORKERS SHORTAGE, QUESTION INDUSTRY'S 'FREE PASS'

SCHOLARS DEBUNK CLAIMS OF HIGH-TECH WORKERS SHORTAGE, QUESTION INDUSTRY'S 'FREE PASS'



by TONY LEE 16 May 2014 368POST A COMMENT

VIDEO AT LINK

Four prominent scholars on Friday questioned why the high-tech industry gets a free pass to perpetuate the myth that there is a shortage of American workers in jobs related to science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM).
Unlike industry lobbyists and politicians who have repeated that claim in an attempt to secure more high-tech visas that would lower the wages of American workers, the scholars presented firm evidence to debunk the notion that the high-tecn industry is suffering from a lack of qualified American workers.

On a Friday conference call that was organized by the office of Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-AL), who has been relentless in standing up for American workers and their interests during the amnesty debate, Hal Salzman, a Rutgers University public policy professor, said current wages in the high-tech and information technology (IT) industries do not reflect a labor shortage.

"Average wages in IT today are the same as they were when Bill Clinton was president well over a decade ago," Salzman said. "So one has to wonder if there is in fact a shortage, why doesn't that reflect in the market? Why don't wages go up?"

Norm Matloff, a professor of computer science at University of California at Davis, simply said, "When you talk about solutions, you have to ask whether there was a problem to begin with."

Michael Teitelbaum, a senior research associate at Harvard Law School whose new book, Falling Behind? Boom, Bust, and the Global Race for Scientific Talent, explores these issues, said as far as he knew, "nobody who is not associated with the industry that is engaged in a rather effective and expensive generalized" campaign to clamor about the "widespread shortages of scientists and engineers" has been able to provide the evidence of such shortages.

Matloff said the high-tech industry has gotten a "free ride" from the media and enjoys a very "positive image" in this debate, which he said has "really been a non-debate."

The myth that there are such widespread labor shortages

in the high-tech industry has been debunked in numerous studies, but Republicans and Democrats have continued to, as the scholars noted, perpetuate it without being challenged on their specious claims. High-tech lobbies like Facebook co-founder Mark Zuckerberg's FWD.us have poured in millions of dollars in high-profile campaigns to secure more high-tech visas.

And they have partly been succeeding. The Senate's amnesty bill that passed last year would double and possibly triple the number of high-tech visas and, as Breitbart News has reported, House Judiciary Committee Chair Rep. Bob Goodlatte's (R-VA) "SKILLS" Act that passed out of his committee would double the number of H-1B visas.
Ron Hira, a public policy professor at the Rochester Institute of Technology who has worked on these issues for more than a decade, said on the conference call that the H-1B visas that are filling the supposed "gaps" are "doing more harm than good" to the U.S. science and engineering workforce.

He noted that the majority of the H-1B visas are being used for "cheaper workers" from abroad and mentioned that offshoring firms used 50% of the cap last year to further their business model of bringing in "lower-cost H-1B workers to replace American workers." Salzman said that even after American software engineers train their replacements, they cannot speak out about their experiences for fear of being blackballed or having to forfeit their severance payments.

Hira said that the H-1B program has run amok because "Congress sets the wage floors way too low" and "far below the market wages for American workers" while not placing any "requirement to look for or recruit American workers first, so there is no displacement of American workers."

"As a result, you are basically inducing companies to game the system to bring foreign workers to undercut American workers," Hira noted. "Instead of complimenting the U.S. workers as it should, it's substituting for the U.S. workforce and taking away future opportunities by shifting the work overseas."

Salzman said that in this arrangement, the employer has nearly total control of the "indentured" H1-B workers because they hold their work permits.

Matloff agreed, saying that figuratively "handcuffing" foreign workers is even "more important than saving on wages" because employers can "prevent foreign workers from leaving" in the middle of projects, unlike with American workers.

He also mentioned that IT guest workers are on pace to make up 30-40% of the entire IT workforce even when there are 50% more graduates than job openings in the STEM fields.

Further, Matloff emphasized that H1-B visa holders earn 5-10% less on average than American workers and there is a high churn rate that gives companies a "never-ending supply of new hires," allowing them to replace workers over the age of 35 while weakening the "bargaining position of current workers." The Senate bill, Matloff said, exacerbates this problem by providing 150% of the visas that the IT industry has said they needed at the beginning of the debate.
"You are replacing more innovative people with less innovative people, which also will amount to a net loss for the U.S. economy," Matloff said, saying, for instance, that there are fewer patents per capita produced by those from abroad than those in America.

As a result, fewer Americans are able to move up the economic ladder through the high-tech fields. And the problem has gotten worse since the H-1B spigots were opened in the 1990s.

"Software development used to be a lifetime career," Matloff, the U.C. Davis professor, said. Hira, the H-1B expert, added that the IT sector has traditionally been "an area of social mobility."

"You've got people who come from working-class backgrounds who go into these sectors," Hira said. "It's a way of getting into the middle class and the professional class, and that's being cut off."

This trend, though, is nothing new, according to Teitelbaum, the Harvard Law School research associate who has discovered that dating back to World War II, there have been five cycles in which alarms were sounded about shortages in the STEM fields that forced the government to respond by increasing the flow of high-tech workers through more education or visas.

What immediately followed, Teitelbaum said, were periods of busts that put workers out of work and discouraged prospective students from going into the those industries, which would lead to another "shortage" cycle. Matloff said there are some indications that students in the STEM fields, even graduates in Silicon Valley, are responding negatively when faced with bleak job prospects in the high-tech industry after they were assured that STEM degrees would secure them employment. Matloff noted that other students may "eventually see that this is not a good career path" and, consistent with Teitelbaum's findings, discourage others from pursuing STEM degrees and potentially sowing the seeds for a sixth cycle of boom and bust.

Teitelbaum declared that such cycles in the high-tech and science industries represent an "unhealthy history" where workers are displaced as jobs become even tougher to find.
"We may be in the process of repeating it," he warned.

As Breitbart News has reported, House Judiciary Committee Chair Rep. Bob Goodlatte's (R-VA) "SKILLS" Act that would double the number of H-1B visas has passed out of his committee.

http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Governm...ry-s-Free-Pass

TAKE ACTION NOW Call (202-224-3121) and ask for your member of Congress to say your own distinct version of....

This is a very powerful message and if enough of you will generate enough calls, Facebook posts, letters, faxes, and emails to Congress, it will put the amnesty faction into disarray!

"I'm calling/writing Congressman _________ to demand that he take action to impeach or arrest Obama instead of trying to help Obama pass immigration reform amnesty for illegal aliens. Is he aware that Obama is releasing tens of thousands of criminal illegal aliens back onto American streets in violation of the current laws of Congress, in violation of his Oath of Office, and in direct violation of the US Constitution? We need our members of Congress to oppose immigration reform amnesty and instead focus on stopping Obama's abuses of power that are accessory to the murders of at least 19 people killed by the illegals he is releasing!"


PS: Don't forget to place your comments on your Congressional Reps social media pages like Facebook. We have the Facebook pages listed for the 50 GOP traitors for you at this link....
http://www.alipac.us/f8/traitor-list-contact-info-proof-amnesty-stance-289229/

Surprise: Amnesty Pushers Are Lying About STEM Worker Shortage

May 21, 2014 by Bob Livingston

THINKSTOCK

One of the main lies promulgated by the amnesty pushers in their propaganda campaign to open up America’s borders is that there is a shortage of American workers with science, technology, engineering and math (STEM) skills to fill the available jobs.
A new report by the Center for Immigration Studies puts that lie to bed, as have previous reports by the Economic Policy Institute, the RAND Corporation, the Urban Institute and the National Research Council.
The CIS study analyzed the latest government data and found that in 2012 there were more than twice as many people with STEM degrees as there were STEM jobs (12.1 million native-born and legal immigrants with STEM degrees versus 5.3 million STEM jobs). Only one-third of American natives with STEM degrees actually work in a STEM occupation. There are 1.5 million Americans with engineering degrees not working as engineers. There are half a million with technology degrees, 400,000 with math degrees and 2.6 million with science degrees not working in their chosen field. There are another 1.2 million Americans with STEM degrees not working at all.
The numbers are bad for legal immigrants as well. Fewer than half of immigrants with STEM degrees work in STEM jobs, and just 23 percent of immigrants with engineering degrees work as engineers. Of the 700,000 STEM workers allowed into the U.S. between 2007 and 2012, only one-third work in a STEM job, another third work in a non-STEM job and a full one-third are unemployed.
In fact, the RAND study found that there has been no shortage STEM workers since 1990 and there is no shortage on the horizon.
Don’t be fooled by the rhetoric. The Republican amnesty push is simply to a ploy to keep wages suppressed for the corporatocracy. It is the agenda of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and of Silicon Valley moguls who fund Republican campaigns. The amnesty push by the Democrats is to fulfill the agenda of the unions, which need millions of potential new union members to prop up their numbers, as well as more automatic Democrat voters.
Neither Republican nor Democratic amnesty backers have the best interests of Americans or America at heart, for granting amnesty to 11 million or 12 million illegals will serve to drive down wages, leave more Americans unemployed and further destroy the middle class. And studies show that Third World immigrants favor socialist policies of unionization, set minimum wages, gun control and nanny state governance.

http://personalliberty.com/surprise-...rker-shortage/

It's a new version of The Arrogance of Power. Tech moguls are demanding special treatment for a condition which does not even exist. The media are servile, congress is servile. Our own people are getting the shaft.

There is no shortage of stem workers, there *is* a surplus of STEM workers.

Polls continue to show that Americans are concerned about jobs and the economy. We could show that we are working to protect their interests by mounting a campaign for Universal E-Verify and a moratorium on immigration, during which we will publicize the true situation of American STEM graduates and workers.
********************************
Americans first in this magnificent country

American jobs for American workers

Fair trade, not free trade