Results 1 to 1 of 1
Thread Information
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
-
11-21-2026, 04:07 PM #1
Supreme Court justices bash lawyer defending the undercutting of American jobs with c
The Western Journal
159.9K Followers
Supreme Court justices bash lawyer defending the undercutting of American jobs with cheap migrant labor
Story by Pete Peterson
• 1h • 3 min read
Supreme Court Justices Bash Lawyer Defending the Undercutting of American Jobs With Cheap Migrant Labor© Daniel Heuer / Bloomberg via Getty Images
The Supreme Court heard oral arguments Nov. 10 for Department of Labor vs. Sun Valley Orchards, with the justices taking turns grilling the latter’s lawyer.
Rob Johnson, arguing on behalf of Sun Valley Orchards, contended that the imposition of penalties over immigration contracts was a power reserved for courts, and not the internal adjudication of the Executive Branch.
Johnson faced criticism from both the liberal and conservative justices on the Supreme Court with Department of Labor (DOL) lawyers also rebutting Johnson, arguing that Supreme Court precedent established that it is within the powers of the Executive Branch to levy such penalties in immigration cases.
“I feel at the base of your argument, Mr. Johnson, you’re trying to get us to think that the H2A program is not an immigration program. But it is an immigration program. It’s all about when do we allow the admission of foreign workers, given the fact that we’re concerned that foreign workers will undercut the economic status of domestic workers,” Associate Justice Elena Kagan said.
The DOL fined Sun Valley Orchards $550,000 in 2015 after an inspection revealed that the living conditions on the farm violated H-2A seasonal agricultural worker program rules meant to protect American workers from being undercut by cheaper foreign labor.
Related video: Donald Trump doesn’t get his way: His administration acted against the law (Dagens.com US)
View on Watch
Dagens.com US
Donald Trump doesn’t get his way: His administration acted against the law
Duration 2:23
Sun Valley Orchards appealed on the basis that these civil penalties are related to contract law and thus should be adjudicated in courts as opposed to internally in the DOL, in accordance with Article Three of the Constitution.
“You’re not arguing in this case, say all that all civil penalties must be [adjudicated through] Article Three?” Associate Justice Brett Kavanaugh asked Johnson.
Johnson agreed.
“So you recognize exceptions, with immigration being one of them?” Kavanaugh continued.
Johnson affirmed.
“But I thought you said earlier that in [the immigration] context all civil penalties should fall under Article Three. Did you say that earlier?” Kavanaugh said.
“So I think that–” Johnson was interrupted.
“Can I get an answer?” Kavanaugh asked.
“Can I distinguish between the rule that I would advocate –” Johnson was interrupted again.
“Can you say ‘yes’ or ‘no’ to him, because I thought you said that too?” Associate Justice Amy Coney Barrett interjected.
“Yes, but I don’t think the Court should go that far in this case,” Johnson said.
“You’re going to need to explain that now,” Kavanaugh said, laughing.
The DOL argued that under the Supreme Court decision in Oceanic Steam Navigation Co. v. Stranahan, there is precedent for the Executive Branch levying fines on corporations breaking immigration law through internal adjudication.
Johnson argued that Oceanic was an immigration admissions case, because at the root of that case was whether boats importing diseased migrants could be fined by the Executive Branch. He contended that the Sun Valley Orchards case was different because the migrants were already in the country.
“I have to tell you, Mr. Johnson, I’m struggling with your argument a little bit. You said that the difference between this case and Oceanic is the nature of the claims and the nature of the remedies. The nature of the claims, you said, ‘well, Oceanic was an admissions case; of course, the government has complete authority to use administrative adjudications with respect to admissions.’ Well, this is also an admissions case. An employer has gone to the government and said, ‘We are going to make various certifications so that you will allow us to bring in a boatload of foreign workers.’ What the government is now saying is that the admissions requirements put on those workers have been violated. Remedy there: civil fines, and so here: civil fines,” Kagan said.
Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor suggested that the purpose of the precedent set in Oceanic makes the ruling still relevant today, even though Oceanic was concerned with admission at the border and Sun Valley Orchards with matters within the country.
“Oceanic was at a time when immigration was totally different […] [but] as soon as immigration became a problem, we had administrative processes to punish employers who have lied to bring people in,” Sotomayor said.
All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact licensing@dailycallernewsfoundation.org.
Supreme Court justices bash lawyer defending the undercutting of American jobs with cheap migrant laborIf you're gonna fight, fight like you're the third monkey on the ramp to Noah's Ark... and brother its starting to rain. Join our efforts to Secure America's Borders and End Illegal Immigration by Joining ALIPAC's E-Mail Alerts network (CLICK HERE)
Similar Threads
-
Justices of the US Supreme Court pose for their official photo at the Supreme Court i
By Airbornesapper07 in forum General DiscussionReplies: 0Last Post: 06-25-2023, 09:44 PM -
Brunson Supreme Court Case Lawyer Interview. Will the Supreme Court Dump Over Half of
By Airbornesapper07 in forum Other Topics News and IssuesReplies: 1Last Post: 12-15-2022, 01:34 PM -
Lawmakers impeach 3 Supreme Court justices
By JohnDoe2 in forum Other Topics News and IssuesReplies: 3Last Post: 08-14-2018, 02:14 PM -
Only 3% of State Supreme Court Justices in U.S. Are Latino
By stevetheroofer in forum General DiscussionReplies: 10Last Post: 04-18-2011, 03:51 PM -
9 Supreme Court Justices: Blood on their hands?
By mirse in forum Other Topics News and IssuesReplies: 8Last Post: 01-18-2009, 06:18 PM


LinkBack URL
About LinkBacks



Reply With Quote

Supreme Court justices bash lawyer defending the undercutting of...
11-21-2026, 04:07 PM in General Discussion