Thread: ICE not removing those they are getting removal orders on

Thursday, February 19, 2009
ICE not removing those they are getting removal orders on

Fox News:


The U.S. government spends tens of millions of dollars each year persuading federal circuit courts to uphold orders for thousands of illegal immigrants to leave the country, but those orders have been enforced in only one-fifth of the cases, according to sources familiar with a recent Justice Department study.

Immigration and Customs Enforcement, a branch of the Department of Homeland Security, is responsible for "removing" illegal immigrants who stay in this country against the law. But the study found that more than 80 percent of the illegal immigrants whose deportation orders were upheld by a federal appeals court last year were still in the country as of five weeks ago, according to an internal Justice Department memo obtained by FOX News.

"If the people aren't getting removed, why the heck are we spending all the money?" asked one former Justice Department official who left with the Bush administration.

Two sources familiar with the memo accompanying the Jan. 16 study said the Justice Department spends at least $20 million each year paying litigators to argue deportation cases in federal appeals courts. But, the former Justice Department official said the total cost to taxpayers is much higher considering the price tag of flying some 300 litigators around the country and putting them up in hotels. That's not to mention the cost for federal and immigration courts to operate so they can hear the cases.

In general, people identified as illegal immigrants first appear before an immigration court, and if they are ordered to leave the country they can appeal that order to the Justice Department's Board of Immigration Appeals and then the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

About 8,000 cases made it to the U.S. Court of Appeals last year and the study tracked the 7,200 cases in which the Justice Department prevailed. The study found that despite winning those cases, only 1,375 illegal immigrants -- 19 percent -- had been removed as of last month.

"If no one's even doing anything after we win, then what's the point?" the former Justice Department official asked. "We're just spinning our wheels."

...

ICE spokeswoman Kelly Nantel wouldn't address whether taxpayer money is being put to good use, but she did insist that the situation is more complex than a single Justice Department memo can reflect.

"It wouldn't be accurate to say that we have not followed up on [these cases]," she said. "The entire process is established with the understanding that these individuals have demonstrated their good faith to show up for hearings. They don't represent a threat to the community or a flight risk." She said that anyone in this country who poses a national security threat or a public safety threat is detained.

The Justice Department study and the subsequent memo address only a small piece of a much larger problem that ICE is trying to dent. According to Nantel, 554,000 cases of people inside the United States who aren't complying with an order of removal are currently working their way through the legal system. That's down 12 percent from just a year and a half ago, she said.

However, Nantel acknowledged that among the 7,200 cases studied by the Justice Department, a portion of them could have involved illegal immigrants who ultimately failed to show up as promised. And she noted that when illegal immigrants reach the end of their appeals and are still ordered removed, there is "a very high percentage who fail to show up."

"Now the challenge is addressing those who --- after having access to all the [legal] processes -- choose to abscond," she said.

http://prairiepundit.blogspot.com/2009/ ... tting.html

FOX news reported several times on this yesterday!!

GWB gang did nothing for over six years, and then with legacy on the line, they began enforcing laws. Obama has been in office for a month and no one really knows what policies he will enact.
I don't understand why we should allow illegals to appeal any decision made by a US Court of Law. They are not citizens and should not clog up our legal system at taxpayer expense, since they rarely contribute to our tax base being paid under the table. Throw the bums out!

Duplicate

http://www.alipac.us/ftopict-146739.html