Thread: Ike aftermath lays bare U.S. immigration paradox

Ike aftermath lays bare U.S. immigration paradox

By Carey Gillam
9/18/08

HOUSTON (Reuters) - The men gather early on street corners here in storm-battered Houston, ready for the jobs they know will come their way, sweeping up broken glass and clearing downed trees and debris from city streets.

They speak mostly Spanish, while looking warily at strangers. And these undocumented, also called illegal, immigrants worry that instead of a job and a day's wages, they might instead find themselves arrested and deported.

Indeed, in the aftermath of Hurricane Ike, which left a trail of destruction across southeast Texas, America's ongoing debate over U.S. immigration policy is again aflame.

On the one hand, the undocumented in the United States -- an estimated 12 million mostly Hispanic individuals -- are seen by some as a needed labor source, particularly after disasters like Ike turn communities to ruin. But many see the group as a drag on government resources who take jobs from Americans and deserve no assistance.

"They don't have resources and they don't have legal status, and we are concerned that they might not ... have water or electricity," said Fernando Garcia, the director of the Border Network for Human Rights, a nonprofit advocacy group.

"People are afraid to reach out for help as they don't know if immigration (police) will detain them or not," he said.

There are more than one million undocumented workers in Texas, with many living in Houston and surrounding areas hit by the hurricane, according to the Border Network.

With drivers' licenses and Social Security numbers as the keys to unlocking government aid, assistance such as emergency food stamps and help with temporary housing are largely unavailable for this population.

"If you are an undocumented worker you are barred from these resources," said Texas Health and Human Services spokeswoman Stephanie Goodman.

Armed with shovels and rakes, undocumented workers have played a role in clearing away the rubble of many of America's natural disasters, including Hurricane Katrina in 2005 and the wildfires that ravaged southern California in 2007.

That factor, combined with evidence that many in the Hispanic population have trouble tapping post-disaster aid, needs reform, advocates said.

"The question of benefits and who can apply after a disaster is a big issue," said The National Council of La Raza spokeswoman Sara Benitez. "That has been a really big issue in the Gulf Coast."

La Raza, a Washington-based advocacy group for Latinos, plans to release a report next month that examines what it sees as unfair treatment of undocumented workers after U.S. disasters, and recommends changes in U.S. policy that specifically would alter disaster assistance programs to benefit Latinos.

But Ira Mehlman, a spokesman for the Federation for American Immigration Reform, said U.S. policy needs to tighten down on undocumented immigrants not expand to embrace them. And he said clean up and rebuilding following disasters such as Hurricane Ike can provide good jobs for unemployed Americans if undocumented workers are shunned.

"Just as it was in the aftermath of Katrina, there are an awful lot of American citizens who need the work," said Mehlman. "There are a lot of people hurting in south Texas right now who could probably use the work and the paycheck."

Amid the debate, with thousands of flooded and wind-battered homes and businesses in need of clean-up and repair across southeast Texas and Louisiana, manual laborers, including undocumented workers, are in high demand.

Laborers are needed everywhere from Houston, the fourth-largest U.S. city, to Galveston Island, a seaside community that once housed 60,000 but now is a deemed so storm-damaged that everyone has been asked to evacuate.

"Everyone went to work yesterday," said Mark Zwick, founder of Casa Juan Diego, an assistance organization that houses, feeds and provides medical care for undocumented immigrants in Houston. "Work had been down, but now there is plenty for them."

(Additional reporting by Tim Gaynor; editing by David Wiessler)

http://www.reuters.com/article/domestic ... 0320080918

Those same illegal aliens standing on the corner have been over at the Salvation Army truck getting a hand out.

There are plenty of Americans that need jobs.

Dixie

Put an American to work...deport an illegal. Besides there are a lot of Americans that would do the work for free just to help out. The illegals will suck the economy dry!

La Raza, a Washington-based advocacy group for Latinos, plans to release a report next month that examines what it sees as unfair treatment of undocumented workers after U.S. disasters, and recommends changes in U.S. policy that specifically would alter disaster assistance programs to benefit Latinos



And if we are not all over THIS immediately, we should be.

I am getting just a little bit more than fed up with La Raza coming up with these ideas for "Latino only" assistance programs. It is discriminatory, racist, and, given the laws of this country against such things, completely against the law.

And that's not EVEN going into the illegality of their actions in assisting illegal aliens in this country.

This seperatist crap of theirs needs to be stopped and it needs to be stopped yesterday.

La Raza, a Washington-based advocacy group for Latinos, plans to release a report next month that examines what it sees as unfair treatment of undocumented workers after U.S. disasters, and recommends changes in U.S. policy that specifically would alter disaster assistance programs to benefit Latinos.

Of course la raza will exploit a natural disaster to argue for even more benefits for their beloved illegal invaders! La raza is insane...

With drivers' licenses and Social Security numbers as the keys to unlocking government aid, assistance such as emergency food stamps and help with temporary housing are largely unavailable for this population.

IT AN "ILLEGAL ALIEN" POPULATION THAT SHOULD BE DEPORTED, NOT CODDLED TO! Our number one priority is assisting Americans with food stamps and temporary housing. Illegal aliens can go back to their homelands for assistance.

Not one penny should be handed as pay to anyone undocumented. And who is doing the hiring of these characters for clean-up, individuals, the cities, the state or the feds? This is aiding and abetting which is illegal. As far as I am concerned, LaRaza and the rest of the pro-illegal gang should be hauled into court.

With the housing sector meltdown (which was propped up by illegal labor in the first plece) there are plenty of construction workers needing jobs.

Since FEMA money will be rescuing this area, that money should be paid to American workers and should remain in the US economy---not sent out by the Billions to Mexico.

That factor, combined with evidence that many in the Hispanic population have trouble tapping post-disaster aid, needs reform, advocates said.

"The question of benefits and who can apply after a disaster is a big issue," said The National Council of La Raza spokeswoman Sara Benitez. "That has been a really big issue in the Gulf Coast."

They should not be eligible for anything at all, that is the issue. This is a perfect time for them to go back to their home countries, we don't want them here!

In addition, volunteers from all over the US come to help in natural disasters. Illegal aliens will not lift a finger unless they are paid. Nice values eh? DEPORT THEM NOW! No excuses.

Amen aswreath......you nailed it perfectly. Not to mention when there was disaster aid in California, there were a number of illegals comming to the area claiming they were in need when in fact they didn't even live there. They were able to track and prosicute some who falsely claimed need during Katrina but how can you for illegals? We don't know who they are. I've seen it way too often where "Latinos" have been given handouts and all they did was turn around and sell it at a flea market. Seems LaRaza should educated "their people" on what's this is about and that it's something you don't ABUSE.

I too am FED-UP with LaRaza and their demands for JUST their people.