Thread: Legal immigrants show they respect citizenship

Legal immigrants show they respect citizenship

I am completely in agreement with the opposing view "Reject birthright citizenship." With all the debate over illegal immigrants and immigration, the effects both are having on native citizens and the value of citizenship are often overlooked (Anchor babies' debate, Aug. 31).

OUR VIEW: Should being born in the USA make you a citizen?

OPPOSING VIEW: Reject birthright citizenship

Illegal immigrants take jobs from Americans, and no, those jobs are not all ones that Americans won't take. When one is out of work; one will take any job that is available.

I always thought American citizenship was to be valued. Immigrants came here to be Americans. Learning English, adapting to customs and valuing the freedom we cherish were the tenets of the dream.

The idea of having babies as a way to obtain citizenship cheapens the whole idea of being American. In my family, the concept of becoming a citizen involved study, work and assimilation.

Steven Aiello; Howard Beach, N.Y.
------------------------------------

'Anchor babies' hard path
As a legal immigrant, I was very interested to read the debate about birthright citizenship — whether babies born to parents who are illegal immigrants should be given U.S. citizenship ("Should being born in the USA make you a citizen?," Our view).

Gaining legal status through family connections is a very difficult process, especially through children. A child born here is a citizen under the Constitution. But that does nothing for the parents. Even if a mother did manage to enter illegally and have a baby, she would still need to wait until the child is 21 to apply for legal citizenship status. That means the parents would have to find illegal work and avoid deportation for 21 years.

When they did apply, the applicants' background, as well as the sponsors' financial stability, would be investigated. If a background check determined that they had been in the country illegally, the application could be denied. The process also involves a face-to-face interview with an immigration officer who is looking for people trying to claim immigration through illegal processes.

Having a child who is a U.S. citizen is no guarantee of citizenship for the family. The truth is that it is much easier to be an illegal immigrant and slip under the radar than it is to go through the process legally.

Stopping "anchor babies" won't stop illegal immigration, or even slow it down. The way to stop illegal immigration is to make it harder for illegal immigrants to find employment in this country.

Fraser Clements; Reading, Pa.

http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/le ... 7_ST_N.htm

No child of illegal aliens should become a US citizen upon birth, and people who think they are under the US Constitution, need to educate themselves on the subject, starting with the 14th Amendment and what the phrase "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" means which of course is exactly what it says.

To quote our US Navy,"ANCHORS AWAY!''

Originally Posted by stevetheroofer

To quote our US Navy,"ANCHORS AWAY!''

Absolutely! Good one, stevetheroofer.