Thread: hillary playing the gender card

Feminists for Clinton?
By David Knowles
Nov 5th 2007 8:41AM
Filed Under:Hillary Clinton, Democrats, 2008 President


To hear the media tell it, a schism has emerged in feminist circles in the wake of last week's Democratic presidential debate. The source of the controversy surrounds Hillary Clinton and whether or not she "played the gender card" to explain away what many deemed a classic display of political parsing. After Clinton turned in her less-than-stellar night in Philadelphia, the spin-room narrative was put this way by one of her advisers: "Ultimately, it was six guys against her, and she came off as one strong woman." Team Hillary slapped together a rapid-response sound bite, "The Politics of Pile On," a crafty phrase (and video) meant to elicit sympathy from female voters. In a subsequent speech at Wellesley College, Clinton's alma matter, Mrs. Clinton observed, "In so many ways, this all-women's college prepared me to compete in the all boys' club of presidential politics."


Photo Gallery: Candidate Spouses




Well, perhaps not every self-described feminist in the audience is shouting out "You go, Girl!" in response. For women like Kate Michelman, the former president of NARAL Pro-Choice America, Mrs. Clinton's alibi is a bit too much to take. From the LA Times:

"When unchallenged, in a comfortable, controlled situation, Sen. Clinton embraces her political elevation into the 'boys club.' But when she's challenged, when legitimate questions are asked, questions she should be prepared to answer and discuss, she is just as quick to raise the white flag and look for a change in the rules. It's trying to have it both ways."
Reuters and The Politico also offer stories today about the feminist debate, both pieces citing Ms. Michelman as evidence of the rift. Naomi Wolf is added to the mix, as well, saying of the Clinton team's decision to deal the gender card,

"They are being very, very strategic," by playing to the sympathies that virtually every woman in a male-dominated professional world can relate to, feminist writer Naomi Wolf said of the Clinton campaign. At the same time, she said, "They are yielding to gender stereotypes."

Of course, there are plenty of women out there who feel differently. The sight of six competitors and two aggressive moderators, all of them men, interrogating Mrs. Clinton before the cameras illustrated just how far we have to go in terms of gender equality. According to Rasmussen, in fact, if you just go on what happened at the Philadelphia debate, minus the spin, Hillary actually increased her lead over her rivals.

The problem for Mrs. Clinton, it seems to me, is the spin itself. Yes, she didn't do all that well for portions of the debate. But by claiming she was a victim, then rescinding that sentiment, only to let it slip back in to her speeches, she has fostered the impression that you cannot trust what she says. And that, for anyone whose memory hasn't deteriorated to the point where John Kerry doesn't ring a bell, is the death knell for a presidential candidate.

Please give me a break. If she can't handle the men in her own party how is she going to handle the big bad men that govern most of the world governments? Poor pitiful Hillary

Hillary hasn't given any REAL answers to anything. She is "playing the gender card"? I'm still trying to figure out what gender Hillary is anyway. I've never seen the feminine side, but I've seen the masculine side. IMO, she fits right in the "all boys club". Sorry, its just my opinion.

I knew that was coming. When I think about her appealing to women all I can think about is an old joke... When the Clintons were in the White House... Hillary demanded to have the toilet seats removed from Camp David and the White House living quarters because she didn't need them.

Dixie

Well this is no surprise from BILLARY. What a complete loser this woman is. She claims to be a victim and cries out to all her feminist buddies to try and spin it in a whole new direction.
Anyone watching the debate that night could clearly tell that she was caught right in the middle of her double talk and flip floppery!

Grow up HITLERY, this has nothing to do with you being a woman, this has everything to do with you and your shady politics.
What kills me is that the very next day, she came out and said she supported his plan.

So why didn't you just say yes the night before during debate BILLARY? This woman is unbelievable, and yet there are idiots out there who think she would make a good president.