Thread: Holder: Feds May Sue Over Arizona Immigration Law

Holder: Feds may sue over Arizona immigration law
By the CNN Wire Staff
May 9, 2010 2:06 p.m. EDT

Attorney General Eric Holder says the Justice Department may sue Arizona over its new immigration law.


Washington (CNN) -- Attorney General Eric Holder said Sunday that the Justice Department was considering a federal lawsuit against Arizona's new immigration law.

"We are considering all of our options. One possibility is filing a lawsuit," Holder told NBC's "Meet the Press." Possible grounds for the lawsuit would be whether the Arizona law could lead to civil rights violations, he said.

The recently enacted Arizona law initially allowed police to ask anyone for proof of legal U.S. residency, based solely on a police officer's suspicion that the person might be in the country illegally. Arizona lawmakers soon amended the law so that officers could check a person's status only if the person had been stopped or arrested for another reason.

Critics say the law will lead to racial profiling, while supporters say it involves no racial profiling and is needed to crack down on increasing crime involving illegal immigrants.

In Arizona, the city councils of Tucson and Flagstaff have decided to challenge the new immigration law in court.

Holder told ABC's "This Week" program that one concern about the Arizona law is that "you'll end up in a situation where people are racially profiled, and that could lead to a wedge drawn between certain communities and law enforcement, which leads to the problem of people in those communities not willing to interact with people in law enforcement, not willing to share information, not willing to be witnesses where law enforcement needs them."

"I think we could potentially get on a slippery slope where people will be picked on because of how they look as opposed to what they have done, and that is, I think, something that we have to try to avoid at all costs," Holder added.

Holder said comprehensive federal immigration reform is the best approach for the problem of illegal immigrants crossing U.S. borders. His stance echoed the approach favored by President Obama, who last week criticized the Arizona law and said he wants Congress to work on the issue this year.

Comprehensive immigration reform would include continuing government efforts to secure borders from illegal immigrants, as well as steps to crack down on businesses that employ them, Obama said at a Cinco de Mayo celebration at the White House.

In addition, he said, those living illegally in the United States would have to pay a penalty and any taxes they owe, learn English and "make themselves right with the law" before starting the process of gaining U.S. citizenship.

http://www.cnn.com/2010/POLITICS/05/09/ ... tml?hpt=T2

Sue the Federal Government for liability and not doing its damn job to protect us. Screw them.

ironic,that obama used the example of person being arrested in icecream shop when a couple of years ago,a 3 year old boy in mississippi was killed by an illegal alien in a ice cream shop

Originally Posted by Tbow009

Sue the Federal Government for liability and not doing its damn job to protect us. Screw them.

MY sentiments exactly!

Well then he'll have to sue the federal government for its immigration laws as well, since the AZ law mirrors fed law.

If they SUE the Federal Government maybe they can subpoena at least some of the communications and meeting data between the top Pols and the agencies that are SUPPOSED to protect us like HOME LAND SECURITY...

Then they should sue themselves. The laws are almost Identical....

Why can't the States sue the Government for not protecting the borders and recoup the medical and social services cost of the illegals to the states?

Why can't the families of the victems of illegals sue the government for refusing to enforce the EXISTING laws?

Just another example of how the federal government does not want to stop illegal immigration imo. One administration after another will not enforce their own immigration laws. How many presidents have you heard say 'we are a nation of laws.'....obviously just a sound bite. Governors plead for National Guard troops and the fed ignore them. Various states ask for reimbursements mainly for illegals in jail and get a small fraction. Due to their inaction a state has the guts to try to enforce federal law and the fed government threatens to sue. Unbelievable!

Originally Posted by DHolmes7

ironic,that obama used the example of person being arrested in icecream shop when a couple of years ago,a 3 year old boy in mississippi was killed by an illegal alien in a ice cream shop

umm that actually was Aurora, Colorado, a Denver suburb