Thread: What Gives on American Jews and Immigration?

What Gives on American Jews and Immigration?

by Peter Beinart Jun 5, 2012 2:01 PM EDT

The Workmen’s Circle has just a released a new poll about the Jewish vote. A couple of tidbits: American Jews are more hostile to Palestinian leaders than they are supportive of Israeli ones. A whopping 78 percent of American Jews think the Palestinians “seek Israel’s destruction.” (A lousy way to phrase thequestion since it conflates turning Israeli into a secular binational state with driving the Jews into the sea). But by a margin of 45 to 22 percent, American Jews also believe that “the Israeli government wants to prevent the emergence of a Palestinian state,” which is to say, they believe that Benjamin Netanyahu is lying. By a margin of 40 to 22 percent, American Jews also want Israel to freeze settlement growth. (Many yids can’t make up their mind). In other words, most American Jews fall somewhere between AIPAC and J Street, a finding that’s consistent with other polling.

In other news we already knew, American Jews are wildly liberal when it comes to sex. They overwhelmingly support gay marriage and abortion rights. They’re a lot less enthusiastic about immigration. A slight plurality opposes “the U.S. government making it possible for illegal immigrants to become U.S. citizens.” On immigration, in fact, American Jews are slightly to the American Jewish leadership’s right. I think Steven M. Cohen, who conducted the poll with Samuel Abrams, has noticed this waning Jewish support for immigration before. It’s intriguing, and depressing, given that many Jews still valorize their Ellis Island roots.

Not quite sure what explains this. I’d suspect that anti-immigrant sentiment is highest near the border and among the Anglo working class, since such populations most often compete with immigrants for services and jobs. But Jews aren’t well represented in either cohort. If you can crack the mystery of Jewish nativism, email us at info@openzion.com, and we’ll post your answer.

What Gives on American Jews and Immigration? - The Daily Beast

If you can crack the mystery of Jewish nativism

The mystery of Jewish 'nativism' is American patriotism and common sense. Illegal immigration is bad for Americans of every race, religion, persuasion, and walk of life and most Jewish Americans are smart enough to know that if America allows millions of current illegal aliens to pursue a path to citizenship that America will descend into eventual 3rd world anarchy. A new voting block of millions of illegal aliens would paralyze any future border or immigration law enforcement leaving American wide open to wave after wave of future illegal immigration. A large percentage of illegal aliens from Central and South America have strong anti-Semitic opinions as well. Most American Jews know that if amnesty is given to illegal aliens that within a decade or so, the predominantly white Christian Americans of European descent that have supported Israel will no longer control America with a plurality of votes and the new controllers that took power through invasion and mass lawlessness are very unlikely to continue to support Israel much to the delight of many Global powers that are using their influence to facilitate this illegal immigration invasion of America. Nativist is just a pejorative insult similar to every other ethnic slur ever uttered. I don't see anyone calling the Israelis nativists for how they deal with the Palestinians or how they are mass deporting north Africans right now.

William Gheen
President of Americans for Legal Immigration PAC
www.alipac.us