Thread: ILLEGALS......answer this question!

Originally Posted by dman1200

Answer me this question. Why do you think Mexicans or any foreigners for that matter have any right to be in this country if they don't fill out the proper documents?

Why do you beat your wife?

I know quite a few illegals and many of them don't want more people to come... unless of course it's a family member.

Please explain to me, Jose, how in the world you could accuse dman1200 of BEATING HIS WIFE?? That is just about as off-the-wall a comment as I have ever heard.

Originally Posted by Bootsie

Please explain to me, Jose, how in the world you could accuse dman1200 of BEATING HIS WIFE?? That is just about as off-the-wall a comment as I have ever heard.

It certainly is off-the-wall. By asking why he beats his wife, I skip an important step: finding out whether or not he beats his wife.

He asked me, "Why do you think Mexicans or any foreigners for that matter have any right to be in this country if they don't fill out the proper documents?" He skipped an important step also: finding out whether or not I think Mexicans or any foreigners for that matter have any right to be in this country if they don't fill out the proper documents.

The question I posed to him was merely to illustrate how off-the-wall his question to me was. And it went right over your head.

Originally Posted by Jose

Originally Posted by dman1200

Answer me this question. Why do you think Mexicans or any foreigners for that matter have any right to be in this country if they don't fill out the proper documents?

Why do you beat your wife?

Why are you being a troll? Is it too hard to answer any questions asked of you? Most of your answers are either personal attacks or insults.

Originally Posted by Brian503a

Is it too hard to answer any questions asked of you?

I was asked a loaded question, Brian.

http://www.fallacyfiles.org/loadques.html

I think this is just another BS artist who wants to bait us. He certainly has nothing cogent to add to discussions so he probably rates being ignored.

Originally Posted by Jose

Originally Posted by Brian503a

Is it too hard to answer any questions asked of you?

I was asked a loaded question, Brian.

http://www.fallacyfiles.org/loadques.html

How is it a loaded question? LegalUSCitizen started this topic and you made what appears to be a comment disagreeing with her position. You were then asked repeatedly to elaborate more clearly where you stand on the issue. Instead you either dodge the questions, or lash out with insults. You have the choice to either answer the questions or not. The attacks are not needed.

However, I think it is only fair if you post a reply to a discussion that you better be prepared to defend your views or postions on the subject. Otherwise it is better if you leave your 2 cents out of it. It appears the tone of your posts are trollish, and the only intent is to get angry responses from people on the forum.

He skipped an important step also: finding out whether or not I think Mexicans or any foreigners for that matter have any right to be in this country if they don't fill out the proper documents.

UH... Because it's our country and we make the rules. Take it up with Antonio López de Santa Anna and the signer of Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo. Maybe ya could dig up their bones and stomp on them if it would make you feel better.

I'm with you, Defens. I don't even understand why we are asking illegals anything or even engaging them in a debate. This is our country, PERIOD.